% 


(     IMAGE  EVALUATIOI^ 
TEST  TARGET  (MT-3) 


// 


^S^ 
^^<^ 


:/- 


r/. 


fA 


1.0 


I.I 


L£12.8 

150     *^* 


■  2.5 
^  1^    12.2 


IL25  i  1.4 


MM 


1.6 


^Sciences 
Corporation 


23  WIST  MAIN  STRICT 

WIBSTIR,N.Y.  MS80 

(716)172-4503 


i\ 


■ss 


^\ 


k 


'^ 


*(lFi*  #■ 


<     . 


^  <••■■ 

'A^: 


fe 


\ «. 


CIHM 
Micrafiche 
Series 
(Monographs) 


7 


ICMH 

Collection  de 
rnicrofiches 
(monographies) 


Canadian  Institute  for  Historical  Microraproductions  /Institut  Canadian  da  microraproductions  historiquas 


> 


'f'l 


Ttchnical  and  Bibliographic  Notes  /  Notat  techniquas  et  bibliographiques 


The 
to  t1 


The  Imtitute  has  attempted  to  obtain  the  b«s)  prigihkl- 
copy  available  for  filming,  ^eaturte  of  this  <iopy  which 
may  be  bibliographically  unique,  which  may  alter  any 
of  ^he  images  in  the  reproduction,  or  which  may 
sigrufficantly  change  th^  usual  method  of  filming,  are 
chfcked  b«low. 


D 
D 


Coloured  covers*/ 
Couverture  de  couleur 

Covers  damaged/ 
Couverture  endommagie 


□  Covers  restored  and/or.  laminated/ 
Couverture  restaurie  et/ou  pellicula 


□  Cover  title  i 
Le  tiitre  de  i 


Cover  title  missing/ 

I  couverture  manque 


D 


Coloured  maps/ 

Cartes  gftographiques  en  couleur 


□  Coloured  ink  (i.e.  other  than  blue  or  black)/ 
Encre  de  couleur  (i.e.  autre  que  bleue  ou  noire) 


n 
n 


Coloured  plates  and/or  illustrations/ 
Planches  et/ou  illustrations  en  couleur 

Bound  with  other  material/ 
Relie  avec  d'autres  documents 

Tight  binding  may  cause  shadows  or  distortion 
along  interior  margin/ 

La  reliure  serrte  peut  causer  de  I'ombre  ou  de  la 
distorsion  le  long  de  la  marge  interieure 


□  Blank  leaves  added  during  restoration  may  appear 
within  the  text.  Whenever  possible,  these  have 
been  omitted  from  filming/ 
II  se  peut  que  certaines  pages  blanches  ajouties 
lors  d'une  restauration  apparaissent  dans  le  texta,  ' 
mais,  lorsque  cela  ^tait  possible,  ees  pages  n'ont 
pas  cti  filmtes. 


D 


Additional  comments:/ 
Commentaires  supplimentaires: 


This  item  is  filmed  at  the  reduction  ratio  checked  below/ 

Ce  document  est  f  ilmi  au  taux  de  rMuction  indiqui  ci-dessous. 

-..lOX _„_J4JL ...„„ i,^__jax-_- 


L'Institut  a  microfilm^  le  meilleur  exemplaire  qu'il 
lui  a  M  possible  de  se  procurer.  Les  details  de  cet 
exemplaire  ^ui  sont  peut-Atre  uniques  du  point  de  vue 
bibliographkiue,  qui  peuvent  modifier  une  image 
reproduite.  ou  qui  peuvent  exiger  une  moldif ication 
dans  la  mithode  normale  de  f  ilmage  sont  ijndiqufe 
ci-dessous. 

□  Coloured  pages/ 
Pages  de  couleur 


□  Pages  damaged/  ^ 

Pages  endommagies    -fs  > 

□  Pages  restored  and/or  laminated/ 
Pagesrestaurtes  et/ou  peiliculWs 

0  Pages  discoloured,  stained  or  foxed/ 
Pages  dteolories,  tacheties  ou  piquees 

□  Pagesdetached/ 
Pages  d^tachies 

'\ 

0Showthrough/ 
Transparence 


The 
posi 
oft! 
filmj 


Orig 

begl 

the 

sion 

othe 

first 

sion 

or  ill 


0 


Quality  of  print  varies/ 
Qualite  inigale  de  Timpression 


I        I  Continuous  pagination/ 


□ 


D 


Pagination  continue 

Includes  index(es)/      ' 
Comprend  un  (des)  index 

Title  on  header  taken  from:  / 
Le  titre  de  I'en-tCte  provient: 

Title  page  of  issue/ 

Page  de  titre  de  la  livraison 


■/ 


The 
shal 
TINI 
whii 

Map 
diffe 
entii 
begi 
right 
requ 
metl 


I        I  Caption  of  issue/ 


D 


Titre  de  depart  de  la  livraison 

Masthead/ 

Generique  (periodiques)  de  ia  livraison 


j^^ 


=22JL: 


2SX      -  JU 


n3e*- 


7 


12X 


16X 


20X 


24  X 


28  X 


32  X 


^; 


■#■; 


ir'X 


The  copy  filmed  here  has  been  reproduced  thanks 
to  the  generosity  of: 

Harold  Campbell  Vaughan  Memorial  Libnry 
Acadia  Univereity 


L'exemplaire  f iimi  f ut  reproduit  grAce  %  la 
gAn4rosit6  de: 

Harold  Campbell  Vaughan  Memorial  Library 
Acadia  University 


>ue 


The  images  appearing  here  are  thd  best  quality    ^ 
possible  considering  the  condition  and  legibility 
of  the  original  copy  and  in  keeping  with  the 
filmjhg  contract  specifications. 


Les  images  suivantes  ont  At*  reprodiiites  avec  le 
plus  grand  soin.  cbmpte  t«nu  de  la  condition  et 
de  la  nettetA  de  l'exemplaire  f ilmA>  et  en 
»conformit6  avec  les  conditions  du  cbntrat  de 
filmage. 


Original  copies  in  printed  paper  covers  are  filmed 
beginning  >with  the  front  cover  and  ending  on 
the  last  page  with  a  printed  or  illustrated  Impres- 
sion, or  the  back  cover  when  appropriate.  All 
other  original  copies  are  filmed  beginning  on  the 
first  page  with  a  printed  or  illustrated  impres- 
sion, and  ending  on  the  last  page  with  a  printed 
or  illustrated  impression. 


Les  exemplaires  originaux  dont  la  couverture  en 
papier  est  imprimte  sont  film6s  en  commen9ant 
par  le  premier  |>lat  et  en  terniinant  soit'par  la 
dffnidre  page  qui  comporte  une  emprelnte 
(Timpression  ou  d'illustration,  soit  par  le  second 
plat,  salon  le  cas.  Tous  les  autres  exemplaires 
originaux  sont  filmAs  en  commenpant  par  la 
premiere  page  qui  comporte  une  emprelnte 
d'impression  ou  d'illustration  et  en  terminant  par 
la  dernlAre  page  qui  comporte  une  telle   ' 
emprelnte. 


The  last  recorded  frame  on  each  microfiche 
shall  contain  the  symbol  — ^(meaning""CON- 
TINUED").  or  the  symbol  V  (meaning  "END"), 
whichever  applies. 


Un  das  symboles  suivants  apparaftra  sur  la 
dernlAre  image  de  cheque  microfiche,  selon  le 
cas:  le  symbole  »►  signifie  "A  SUIVRE",  le 
symbole  V  signifie  "FIN". 


IVIaps,  plates,  charts,  etc.,  may  be  filmed  at 
different  reduction  ratios.  Those  too  large  to  be 
entirely  included  in  one  exposure  are  filmed 
beginning  in  the  upper  left  hand  corner,  left  to 
right  and  top  to  bottom,  as  many  frames  as 
required.  The  following  diagrams  illustrate  the 
method: 


Les  cartes,  planches,  tableaux,  etc.,  peuvent  Atre 
filmto  A  des  taux  de  reduction  diff Arents. 
Lorsque  le  document  est  trop  grand  pour  Atre 
reproduit  en  un  seul  clichA,  il  est  filmA  A  partir 
de  Tangle  supArieur  gauche,  de  gauqhe  A  droite. 
et  de  haut  en  bas.  en  prenant  le  nombre 
d'images  nAcessaire.  Les  diagrammes  suivants 
illustrent  la  mAthode. 


% 


.'■,•*» 

V  % 

1 

2 

3 

I  ■, 

!♦<■    .' 


6 


f J  ■  • 


'K  *_^, 


;#^4i^: 


^il^B«A£ 


',.■1 


1^ 


!*t*<t 


%  ■< 


/      ' 


4l 


'<i  ,  i. 


/%  .' 


^m 


•» 


.V* 


'.1! 


'•'*..    K 


■M 


'^% 


<^''^l 


»    > 


I  - 


^A%^^,  <^y^  -*'^^"'!  '^'■^^«^%  •' 


inCliii 
•entea 
«amei 
Til 
Davis 


Atru 


%■' 


li''- 


>;^^H 


l^.v 


t^ 


^f 


•. 


'^ 


-(- 


'■«fi 


A' 


■     -A 


'*ffr 


>       "  QEXERIL  ORDERg. 

i  r«  *  ^        ^  1*.  fl^i^i^Brfer^  HMtwi,  18  Oct.  isia. 
*  The  i3«faena  C3^  »akiai^«Iwreof  Maj.  Gen.  Jonathaii 
Dav.8  is  Pre.ident|^pi0ilrti|ii|^  tri»i  of  Maj.  G^n.  Eben- 
e2erGoodale;^f  t^e  6ceo»ypaitBpoi.  the  complaint  of 
Lt  Col.  8anl«dj||,iad<;|r^  ^eUwn,  a.  .et  forth  in  six 
arti||e8  or  speeiiP^i  of  charge  against  hiai»  having  sat 
*°^«'J.  the  "fi*  Maj.  Qen.  Sh^neier  Gtiodale, ",p«n  the 
eomflkint  ^ffresdtl,  have  adjadged>ha^  lie  ia  not  gniky  of  the 
l»t  ajd  8d  ^eleior  .peoifie*tidn.  of  cliilg^  lot  &ai  he  is 
guilty^of  the  3d,  4h,  5th,  i^imI  et|i  artit^M  ot  tpecifieations  of 
chargfe  in  laid  complaint,  and  theienpoQ  We  aenleneea  him 
tp  be  remoTed  from  hi*  officp^  and  Ridged  IdnC  ditqnalifief 
for  and  incapable  of  tel^itg  •ny.miUtaiy  ^«ie,  under  this 
commonwealth,  m  the  terpn  Af  fiye  y^w.     The  Commander 
in  Chief,  having  seen  utatfblK  considered  tht  proceedii^  and 
sentence  of  the  court,  ap|^ri»vw  theilt^  «nl  orders  that  the 
same' be  carried  into  eAwt    ,.      •>  '  "aifcS- 

The  ^eral  Courtjifertial,  wh.ffifaj.  ien.  Jonathan 
Davis  18  President,  is  Milved.  ^*  ^ 

ByarderoftheConunan^rinChief,       ^, 

^pU4AM  DONNlSONi  ^.  Gen. 
A  true  copy.  Attest,  ^^' 

WILUAM  DO 


%. 


^ 


>^ 


€ 


4i 


/^ 


*..'MI 


>>Jl'  !<.■* 


. /-^s^'.S  ji">' 


?# 


«•»• 


;- 


16 


^      " 


0,^' 

m^' 


«^A-f 


^ 


:i^- 


ifr+5 


"'^ 


■,«*r. 


!V;;tt*.1?.'  t 


m 


B 


'IS 


,^■• 


1 


Mune 


i4- 


,.^«wrjiiMiwpi>ii    <ia?^ 


-I      fWi'*.       «  JL.t 


*fl*£J 


s--^. 


I^Vi«>i^u^  .  K^M 


-'ii/.:^i 


RECORD. 


1^ 


4 

'% 


•".if 


M- 


m        ^  nttSEITT 

ii^aj.  den,  JONATOAN^.iniLriS  of  the  7thDiv.  President. 

,    Bt^.  Gin.  NATHiuii£'i|k|tN,  lat  Brig.  8d  Dit. 
Brig.  Gen.  pAiaB^TRA€¥CT«t|lrig.  «Ui  Div. 
Brw.  Gen.  AlM|||D'^Winl>  8d  Brig.  1st  Div. 
LeCol.  RICHiSuf  E..NEWCOMBt  sd  R.  3d  B.  4th  Dir. 
Li.  Col.  JOSE^  FARN8W0RTR,  «th  R.  lat  B.7thDiT. 
lit  Col.  l^TBR  OSGOOD,  Sd  R.  Sd  B.  lat  Div. 
,  Lt  Col.  JOPTATOAN  PAGE,  »tli  R.  f  at  B.  8d  Dir. 
Lt.  Col.  CAliEB  HOWARD,  8d  R.  lat  B.  ffth  Bin 
Lt  Col.  SOLOMON  ^.  CRAB^ERLAIN,  8d  R.  2d  B. 
M^.  ISn^L  DBANE/9d  R.  ad  B.  0th  Div.      [otii  Div. 
M«^.  ALANSON  KPfOX,  4th  H.  iaf.  ^.  4th  Div^ 
Miy.  THOMAS  WHBELBR,  sd  a  lat  B-  7ih  Div. 

SVPSKKVmEBAatgS,  ** 

Maj.  THOMAS  DRURY,  lat  R.  latB.  rth  Div. 

Maj.  JOf  EP^  ED^ARTON,  aA  R.  j|4  3.  «d  Oiv. 

■;       ■  ^  ■-'  .■'        ..,  .■  j'-i  ■ 

JvDGz  JiarocAn. 
Maj.  JOHN  YARiajM|.  3d  Div.  b' 

M^.  JONATHAN  FBiqUNS,  lat  R.  lat  B,  2d  D.  Manhal. 

rsB  eomplainanta  a^  respondeat,  on  being  called,  an- 
swered. The  ordera  for  holding  the  eonrt  and  postponing  the 
aame  wer?  then  read  bjr  the  Judge  Advoeate;  the  originaUi 
being  papers  marked  No.  1  and  3,  are  aaaezed  to  theae  pro- 
eeedings.  The  eoort  waa  then  ordered  to  be  opened,  whieh 
'  was  done  in  doe  forpu  bjr  jthe  Manhal.  ' 

The  Jn^  Advocate  then  prsieeeded  to  adiMiidister  to  th« 
Presideat  and  eaeh  of  the  members  afor«saii,  tUgly,  and  the 


n*. 


'i>* 


k\.'  s-'.'V    'i&J' 


• 


^jH( 


i< 


2»7        ,  -n. 


*•■ 


y  ■#{ 


6 

Preaident  to  the  Judge  Advocate  #1.       ' 

-cnVd  in  .„d  b^  tte  «.t  .LTol'  ^  '*r««^«  »*th..  pre- 

"«g  .he  militia  of  the  cL^o^Hrt  »*  T"'"'^'  ""*  *'^- 

■  '"^•'"''  *^k  a  ..at  near  tlTelj-P!       *'"^""v»fte'-  being 

Gen.  Gooi^Ue  then  ftand-l  fSlf.  t  ^  .  ^         . 

^vhi,h  wa.  rc^m  to  the^^,^'"^^  A'*^*^^  a  papfer, 
"te-,  which  wa.  «ra«teai||ffl3^  »'  'hirty^iin- 

*nd  annexed  to  <he  p«,eJ3Br  *  "****  *••  «» 

The  Judge  Advocate  th.JiJkL»:^^%  „^    •       ,  ' 
fcada»yobjecUo,.again.t,ori,htZ^S!     r*»»«#         . 
a«^  hereupon  h.  au..^,  ^^  HlZ^l^^f  ''*  *^"^- 
tion  being  put  to  the  eompJainaiit.   1^  %  •^eq«»e«- 

»«ad  no  ohjection,  to  „^.^  •"•"'•'  **''y*»»''«l^  that  thej 

Gen:  Obodale  ^  n^        ~  .    ,         - 

J^t  Col.  8an.ucI.Bria.blcco^^:';:f  "^^  ^^^^pUiat  .f 
^va.  reml  to  hin,  by  the  Judge  Adv^r  ?*'"''*>]''"'  '''»i«* 
which,  being  marked  No  4  T  -^"'^-  4  eertiAcd  copy  of 
Which  being  ..adt^^c  J^;  Jra!?  j:r  ^^^  ^^^^^ 
Ebenezcr  Goodale,  w^thef  ol"  t7  .'*'8"'''^^"^''  «-• 
complaint,  he  wa.  guilty,  o/not  ^Ht^      «"  '"  ^"^  *«»««^*' 

Gen.  Goodale  then  4uled  a  S^ 
the  original  of  which  iT^tiTZT'^T' ""''  '^^^^^ 
proceeding..  Herenpo.  the  court  Z'l'^^  '""'"'^  ^  «>« 
«"ltation,  the  doo«  were  ordeJd  JI!  '^^'  ^"^  aAercon- 
directed  the  Judge  AdvoTtetl  ^JT*^*  •««»  the  co,»rt 
"The  court  eo..Wer,  thaUnV^  ^en.  Goodale,  that 
«  soldier  i8^o  be  con.idcred  «  «^;*n»«t»rt  treiy  citizen 

"  the  public  tribunal  iTlrr"""'  *"  '•>  -«»«t  to 
"  *»'e  door,to  free  inouiry   ^^.f  «7^«»  ought  not  to  .hut 

"Goodale,  a.  commanding  oler  TT^.   ?«— -f  Gen.  j 
"  «-ee,  or  after  the  di.bC:f"*'^^^^^^^ 


n 


IJ  **^;ri^^ 


ltM'i'rti'rt»iii-"4'y  Ti'rill'    V  1 


,«tw;in»f#«»«^f.-H  ^"wflas-i. 


« 


^'itivti  o«th«,  pre- 
»f  the  Legi,ia. 
•»pMsed  March 
raing,  and  train- 
J-  Thoma*  Dru-  ■ 
iM^aAer  being 

'▼Oteate  a  papfer, 
yofthirtjry^in. 

.  '■  ^      ■ 
.Goodaleiriie 
f  of  the  court: 
^Mjneqnea- 
f*a  that  thej 

«ompIaint  of 
tfl'm,  which 
Hned  copy  of 
Ifroceedinga. 
'ot  said  Gen. 
Jie  aforetttid 

hl»  aoawei; 
lexed  to  the 
Rafter  con- 
id  the  eolirt 
»dale,  that 
•»y  eitizcn 
Bondut  to 
iot  to  shut  ; 
r  t)f  Gen.  > 
n  the  ah-    \ 

••i?«:e»^nt  \ 

i^^NMideot      \ 
UieiBojR.    '  \ 


plaiit  aforesaid.-  Hereupon  Gen.  Ooodal.  Wrf  fc;,  .„^„ 

ed  No  7  T  •'"'«*' "  *'•  -■-'He  which  C^'::k 

edNo.8,andannexedtotheproc«^r;g,.  1*1^  "^k- 

The  Jadge  Advocate  then  niored  tL  cimr*  #k.  >  *  ^ 

•'Wene.  i„  behalf  oAth.  JZ^T     k    .   '  '^'"*^  "*^ 

at  what  time?  '-liffij^^  ^'"^ 

eember  lait.  ^  ****.  *^  * J««A  •'>^ 

•aid.    The  oriJ^TT  !^^       «Mr4fc  «  the  ena^aint  iifore. 

•4.  In  180*  I  joined  the  %Ie«i  o«lo<  ^^1-,  ^         , 
ieco«nia.dofCapt.Bowdi<ch.*»Jk.    ••^J*  BQW  nBdef 

«i»char«e,exceptC;^r^t':i;r^^ 

.iTcd  th,  fi«t  Bptice,  I  wen3fc  V  V.   T***'  •*»*  »  ^e- 
.er*rfS.  *^^    •"'***'*•**▼•  Mdiwl»ar«-I«. 

;««..«,-»,  t^tal^k^  sit**''' "  "" 


*t 


/^ 


L*  ti- 


S~ 


# 


»&"!# 


»       i 


sMl; 


1  »'-^ 


i>^ji)ii..>i^ 


J^i*"^.  rf»"'"«f 


/" 


if.     '' 


tV-!.- 


6 


f 


i^^'       J.  I  Bffffer  did  «MMe  to  be  a  menib<r.        ''    - 
r  ^.  ^«im«.    What  adfiM  did  Gen.  Cbwlale  >tt«  yM, 

:Midii^whatteniu,  at  W»bb*tP        , 

4.  He  adTiied  us  not  to  do  doty  ih  tl.  militia  oompairies, 
•nd  told  Of,  if  we  were  not  wanM  io  (^  Cadet  eomaany.  wo 
•fcottM  be  eloar  of  duty.        *j|  ^      ^      -. 

A  He  did  aot  aMi^|||;4il!»;  bat  .atd  hehatfgiTM,  noj 
order  to  hare  as  diMhaq^r  ,.  [  ' 

«;^a|««.  Wa.wi^eiiyiifia^lhaaexaiDiaed,ai,dl 
did  Bot  Oen.  Ooodale  thea  deelare  it  #a^  hi*  •dj^ioo  tou  had  i 
not  been  diselarged? 

4.  I  do  not  reebU^t  thlit  the  law^  eaanined,  bit  the  I 
brigade  book  #a«,  awT  it  did  not  appear  there,  thai  we  had 
been  diiehaiKed.  I  have  not  done  mUitary  dttty  ubmi  July  %, 
1811a  ;  I  *  ^      ^         ^f        "       ^  ^ 

fl  By  MiM.    Why  did  yon  not  do  ftilitary  daty? 

Ji.  Capt.  Bowditeh  did  not  warn  us,  and  Gen.  Goodale  ad- 
Tited  ua  not  to  do  duly  in  the  itanding  miliUa? 

Q.  By  same.  Did  he  advise  yon  not  to  do  daty  in  th«  Cadet 
Company?  -.1 

S.  Noj  he  d^  if  we  wne  not  warned  in  the  Cadet{ 
eompany,  we  should  be  ezensad  |(oni  nilitaiy  duty. 

H,  By  Mme.  Did  he  tell  you,  that  yon  were  mat  UtMe  to  I 
do  do|fy  la^e  Cadet  eonpfuiyP  [ 

Jl,  Noj   I  presomejke  kneliwe  were  member*  of  theUCa- 
det  eompany.  i 

Benjamin  Webb,  b^ihg  duly  sworn,  was  interrogated  As 
Ibllows.  ,»      ,       '  j^^  I 

9f  BjfJ-  ^.    What  do  you  know  relative  to  the  third 

ehat^ge  in  the  complaint?  •  '  '.      .  »^    ,    . 

A  UB^u  l«n,llh Nathan  Cook,  oaeof  tie  e^Ued 
>ienibei>i  of  the  Cadet  einpany,  ealM  on  me,  and  requested 
•e  to  go  with  him  to  ^rig.  MaJ.  White,  and  see  if  theie  was 
any  nenil  of  kis  di^efiarge  in  the bri^e  books.  I  tkenheld 
«n  Ensign's  eemmission  in  the  Cadet  eompany.     Mi^.  White  [ 


/, 


X 


'"^r^ff. 


%U'll4mBlt>  M.TT 


k#^*^?r^1 


f 


3(Md«le  gite  you', 

militm  eompainei, 
Mlet  «oiB|Ma7y  '•'•j 

gi^ibi^ -giViagUii 

IdhehU'gifMiiwI 

luuiexaiDiBed,aiid* 
»  o^ion  you  had  J 

exaninedybitthej 
here,  thai  ¥ft  had) 
iitysiiiM  July  4^1 

wyduty?' 

Oeq.  Gaodale  ad- 

»^ 

duty  in  th«  Cadetj 

Ml  in  the  Cadet] 

f  duty. 

wtte  not  ^Me  lo\ 

c  I 

iben  of  theUCa>| 

interrogated  As] 

ive  to  tke  third! 

of  the  expelled] 
!,  and  requested  I 
eeif  there  waal 
a.  Itkenheldl 
Mi^.  White] 


#" 


.   * 


.v1 


j^d  ut,  that  Oen.  Goodale  would  probablyhe  io  l«w»  4^  9$- 

V  tenioon,  and  m'eef  the  peraont  expfelled  from  the  Cad#  ooa- 
paoy  atj^my  tbop;  and  Oen.  Goodie  i^nd  .Vli^.  Wh.ic  B^thein 

;     Here  iftebr^ingly.      They  told  Oea.*'Ouodai^  &^  eoniAred 
'  t)»eiBMli(|«SiemJ^iifU||^  Cadet  eoaip^     'bnt^d  revived 

notice,  to  llo  duty  in  th<^  ttuiJing  militia  «o«|N|uijM|   aM^to-  < 
'  H*^^  *^^'^'*y  ""^^t  %y  ^M  do  Sty  or  aot^the 

V  miliUa'eo^paniei.  0«q^oo{|^enj^  tham,  Mi«y  i^ere 
Cft^  intents  •<^>P^p*jrigtoillto''of  the  Ca4et  eompanyi 
that,  0«i*t.'Bowakchniad  lo  ri^t  to  dUehaVge  them,  and 
would  be  eomg||||i  to  refteire  then  faek  iigain.  .  He  also  ad- 
riifed  them  Hot  to  pay jiny  attention  to  the  uotiees  of  the  offi- 
eert  of  the  itanding  militia  to  do  duty  in  th«ir  eompaqies*.  He 
fuggeited  ifi  thA,  they  M  better  aaU  on  |he  officers,  and  in- 
fbnn  them  they>  were  menbars  of  the  Ci^tleompkny.  ^ 

^     q.  Bi/OituGood^^   Did  Q«ii.Qo9daler>peate<||iy  enjoin 
;  on  the  members  of^m  Cadcit  iSompaoy,  to.eall  on  the  officers 

of  the  standing  companies,  to  notify.  tliem,th^  \^er^^.«pcmbeiii. 

•f  the  Salen'Cadft  company?  ;v.    *" 

J.  Ht^M  oneo»  at  the  sipggestion  of ^ig.  Whil^.  . 
Capt.  9amael  Chamberlain,  commander  of  a  eompany  of 

militia  in  Salem,  beii%  duly  sworn,  w^  interrogated  as  iollowt. 
q.  By  J.  ML  'What  did  Gton.  OlMale  say  to  you  relatire    ' 

to  .proseentiiig  ^aarnl  Jriggs  f<ir  a  fine,  for  nogfeet  of  duty  in 

yourlonipanyl  v  /  .^'l  .i,^^.-^ 

J:  Said  Briggs  was  ^hsUed  in  my  eompfuy  last  fall,  and 
-^U  he  was  wat>ned,  hec^lpe  to  ne  to  make  his  eaeuse;  and 

•aid' Gen.  Ooodale  and  Mi^.  White  iold,him  he  was  a  member 
'  ^^^  Cadet  flitmpany;  bat  I  t4|ld  hin  I  did  not  think  that  was 

w|r'etense.^  He  also  said,  he  could  fetch  it  firom  •under  their 
'  ftdnds,  that  he  was  a  member  of  the  Cad»t  company,    t  told' 

him^ifheeonld  bring  it  from  4tnder  Capt  Qowditch^s  hands 
^t  woMd  ankwen    I  called  on  Gen.  Qood^Iast  spring,  and 

asked  liim  u|he.w4s  going  to  ealla  eonrt,of  %]|^iry  on  Capt. 

Brtwditeh,  a|d  he  aaawered  yeii,#nd  a|id  ^  |lraj4«i  hare  done 

H  b«fbro,  if,  thoy  had  not  treated  hia/iiktp^ilel^   I  told  him 


.#; 


.•\ 


■  / 

f-r" 

•      .            ■    • 

• 

■'.'» 

, 

' 

..^  > 

■    ;         '^^ 

'  ^  ■■ 

■     t 

s 

'  •            ^ 

,:S^ 


^>-.-V; 


r 


-"£§-,* 


^:.- 


,.  * 
r  . 


m 


t^-^ 


i,;i^^ 


10 
/ff^^.fcj«u  would,  ,^^^^^^^^^ 

*r  fe  pn^^  ^^^^\JJ|g  not  idv«e  aii^il^ 

"f^d  *ih*  competent  ^Li?^"'^^^  . 

ft*queBt  and  «omwon  wlSTrfd^^  T*  ^  qufe-tiw,  1 

«t.  and  «,at  ,*yed  n,e  the  troable     *       ^#^  •^-  ««« 

*  %  fame.  ,^.W««  not  0»»  nl  J  »     ^^      '  « 

Se-tly  pressed  to  c«v«a«4«^L^^     58"^*'^'  »-*«'^^ 


yourself^      '.   w^v 

*  By  '^n,,  ^  How.  came  8am«ellr^     ^  «»«ten«i«ej|^ 
"«?°>PW  °*""***»»  «i  the  roU  of 


pan/.  ®*^  ■    ;*r**einJber«riiii^o»t 

At  half  pMt  8  o'eUyl  p  *,  .fc^-^i^ 
•4|o«rnedto4o^y.,,J'^^ 

.4.  *  •'■*'   1^14      :., 


•t 


•jr 


''3  ( 


I'^flSH"*''^ 


lot  f^is  qufegUon  t 
••pule?    *H,^.^. 

jpiKMfyelM  tried 

'    t         -  »  ■ 

gnently,  au^uN 
>wia  ipiesUoa,  (^ 

ii'M  detentjaeili^ 
«a  the  n»U  of 

^McijBwIer 
oiJered  i«  be 

Ud  OD, 


I 


■|;w 


-'rt» 


:':V,'% 


11        -^        . 

• 

.^  A  Itoli^mi  the  C«det  eomiiny,  is  it«jR 
wiMideKd/iB|MHUember  to  thig  timft.  Qb  ft^ 
aept^nlier  lifil  k^  informed  l|^  the  Clerk  ^^* 
^<WHipiy^^f  militia,  iq  whese  limits  I  residoi^'  i|ii 
^'**i(p^"e|ihi»fW»pany:  Md  afteriv«r(||kiri 
ti  d^dw^in'lbe  eoiqpaoy^But  I  did  nut^aJ&m 

ailMMl»r^ateomi&4^  WHpi^lwl 

during  the  eeiwepationorefeiired  ^«i.d  wheiJ'^the  bngade 

ho«k  iru  brottgh^  it  appeare'S  tlieri^orded,  that  I  wa*  dis- 

ebai8«lfrQiB  t||^adet  eomnliny,  at  my  own  juguegtj-  but  I 

informed  Gen.  Goodale,  that  I  did  not  request  ^|nd  he  said 

he  had  not  authorized  that  reeord  to  be  made,  and  Twas  a 

■member  of  ^e  Cfcdet  company,  aa  i^neh  as  I  ever  was,  and 

tdyued  me  not  to  do  duty  in  the  standinf  militia,  «bd  that  if 

IfM  not  warned  W  the  Cadet  eompany,  I  should  be  elear  of 

duty.    He  also  «^rismie  to  ea)l  on  the  Capt  o|  the  militia 

company,  and  make  mj  exeuse,  which  I  foUoweC  althlmgh  it 

was  differsfilt  from  my  own  opinion.  » 

41  By  deft.  For  what  reason  did  Gen.  Goodale  advise 
you  to  try  the.question'of  yiir  liabiUty  to  do  duty  in  either  of 
the  eompanies? 

■,  •«•  2*f*»«*«Niji'^w««oafc 

'^^^Sf*****'  ^^*Sr*"  *«  «onver»ti6n  at  that  time?* 
A^  da  not  recollect  much  of  it;  ure  were  eonrersing  about 
fte  e^»^t  against  Cap^.  Bowdit^h,  and  Jiaving  heanl,  that 
Optt.  G^iaie  was  not  gef  g  to  niKtiee  the  complaint,  because 
hivwai  «ot  oflleiaUy  notiftid  of  the  discharge  of  Gen.  Oerbv 
Ujj»*id*  if  that  wii  the  case,  and  heslUd  «ri»«ething  li 
ttpilMi»  ;ffle  alsa  asMine  several  tiiaa,  why*  would  not 
have  a  trial  0*.  the  cotaplaiht  aHiM^nie,  for  negleet  of  dltv 
i»t^  standing  mUitia»  and  ui^  me  to  have  it  tri^. 

t^fa^amin  Wehh  was  again  called  on  thajili  e|iirge ' 
m^^m    What  Jlr^ou  know  rehi^^Oen.  Good. 
^!fy^ hi.  a«therity  to  Brig.  M^.  ^»^iSt!^«.ha.g, 

A  taat  May  1  heatd  him  aeknoi^iijglfilfl^W  dele. 


rf# 


5      *f*n 


^^) 


I  -) 


.#  # 


BW/ 


?.(M  ^  .'^C«fP 


^■•,"?P!r? 


IS 


9f^hotitj  to  ifaj.  White,  for 


t^^M  these  thlugg.     He^psaid 

bftsine*  ia  his  ab8eiiir*a|  that  he  had 


ft 


id,  that  Miy, 


ip  the  Bcveral  companies  to  cAll  oo  Mai; 


id  f^m 


^y  wished  any  privates  diBcik_p„  ,^„ 
P?  Im!  had  ^venja^  White  •J^eSl^yder 

i^re^lgli^^  4^  aworn;#int2h^t:. 

ed,  ai|^  answered  ^  fol^g.  * 

«•  ^J"%^  y^h^Mt  youlcnoir  relative  to  Gen.  Go*d. 
ale  .  authorizing  Mi^.  #ite  to  discharge  ji^at,.  W  vol. 
anteer  eon^anies?  ^^^        ,       ^^   i 

A  1  was  eouusel  fop  Mr.  Pope  and  Mr.  Worcester  beftf. 
J.  E.  Sp^igue  Esq.  in  their  trial,  which  took  plaee  last  spring, 
on  a  co^plafpt  for  «ot  dow^  du^  in  the  standing  militi.. 
Their  defence  WM,  that  they  were  members  of  the  Cad«t 
eompaj,y  .^d  ..t  liable  to  do  duty*  dl^^ther  compai^ 
Gen.  Qoodale  wa«  called  as  *  witness  to  testfl|,  whetherthey 
were  discharged  from  the  Cadet  company  oi*  not,'«s  he  wa. 

kim  .f  he  had  d.«.harged  «id  P^eor  Worcestw,  an*  he  tes- 
tified that  he  eould  not  recollect  dischai^ing  either  of  tM«l, 
for  he^len  that^asineifto  Maj,  #h^-He  .«d  Capt.  Bow. 
djtch  had  applited  to  him  for  so«e  dl||^,^„  and  Wnrfbrred 
kim  to  Maj.  ^ite,  and  said,  A|aj.  White  attend,  to  tllM  ba.. 
Messi  and  the  fuldiers  were  acquitted  accordingly,     .. 

J.  E.  Sprague  Esq.  being  duiy  .toi*,  was  interwJted,  and 
wwwered  as  follows.  *  /^ ,  '  ' 

Jl-  ^lfV.^4.  Upoh  Whai  grdtfnds  did  yoi  KiaitJPfcpi 
g^or«?.ter,  who  Wer^  Ujd  b^lbw  yoo  ftr  iegloct  •fti^ 
*thp  ataoitiBg  militia?;-,    i  '  ■  \-»  "■'■v-  ^.'.s*^,,  ,■  ,,^ 

^  A  Th«  gr^  of  tl^if  fefee^gg,  thjit  they  wei*  mm. 
fters  of  ttwCafl  company,  and  m  liable  to  do  dnty  {•  the 
■"^^W^:^"^^-^^^^  -fcuhtof  tliefcgWI^, 

,^l  ^^^;  them,    1 -Sboia  mm  tl^i^  ^^ 


^ 


w 


'M  inccBtftiiijeot 


[sud,  that  Miy% 
Am  that  he  had 
to  c&ll  on  Maj: 
di8c|a|pd  f^om 
ea»^jieial,«^er 

i,lRlinteiT(i^t< 

ef^^Ofea.  Govd. 
|^at«s  iroiftyolf 

Vonnter  befdfa 
laee^last  spring, 
tanding  militia. 
»  of  the  Ca^. 
ither  eompanj, 
%  whether  they 
'  not,  as  he  was 
themf  I  asked 
ten  ai^llMites- 
iither  of  tiieni} 
ud  Capt.  Bow. 
ind  Jm  refJBired 
idstotMUbu. 


:t. -'.t. 


egleetuNi^ 


t>V-i"<». 


'-'■■■J: 


By'#ere  tutm- 
lo  duty  !■  thf) 
'  the  IegU%, 
deteMlpMl^^ 
IHi«e^  iMr 


-'^i'Kv 


(0,  ^tf  time.    W^t  did  Gen.  Goodftle  ^7  »Hii  (lel!^»&> 
».^U  iu.horitTlii|tN^te  to  diS^^ 

rolaateer  eompi«prar  ^. ,  ^_,  . .  „^ 

4.  After  the  examination  of  anamb^r 
iugfL  was  iittRunied  on  aeeoani  of  the 
lalej  bati^S^eiyOen.Gotjdalee^i  . 
lagain  OMS^d,  6en/Goodh||^«ta4Bqniired  6titW\ 
U^m^  eithef^i|h|gJoi.^^ 
Cadet  eompany;  he  answered,  tharne  haiaoraere* 
flhar^es  froofi  the  iCft^et  e(nn|iany,  bit  eould  not  deteiluna 
I  that  he  had  ordemi  the  diaeliarefe  of  eithisr  of-  the  persons  on 
'  Uial^  is  he  kept  nomemoriaiidnm  of  them. 

q,  ffj  court.  Did  Gen.  Goodale  state  that  he  had  giv- 
en order!  to  Maj.  White  to  disieharigie  thi&ia?  ^ 

JJ.  Byeottrt'  Did  not  INS.  Spakle  state,  that  he  had 
gi^  a  general  ordei^  l^aji  Wkte,  to  discharge  privates 
from  Toluntlser  eompaiiies?  ^ 

^.  No;  B|it  said  he  had  given  brders  to  Capt.  Bpwditfch  to 
call  on  M4.  White  with^jparticilar  names,  and^he  would  givo 
them  a  discharge.  \l  think  he  paiii' he  had  given  Cftpt  Bow- 
ditch  sueh  orders  mor«  than  onee. 

Cftpt^^l^flii  C.,^^ri|^^  eomi|y|nder  of  a  eompany  of 
Artiliwryii^Jll^iyef^^^l^i^o^^  answer- 

ed  as  fillflkii*, 

q.  B|t^.  J<f..  What  4a  yon  know  rela^tive  to  Oell.  Good- 
ale*s  andiiorizing  MaJ.  White  to  grant  4iseharges  fh>m  volun- 
teer companies?        ■    ^   «v 

Jl.  I  ealled  on  .Gen  Goodale,  last  winter,  for  the  purpose 
of  pmeuring  the  discharge  of  a  private  in  my  company}  and 
me  to  direct  a  line  to  Maj.  White,  and  he  woold 

MftlWpblil^aay,  I  mpst  wndttieir  namiitiiMftj.  WMte, 
«a«  k9  <#«iii  «seh9rge  them.     1  aeedrdiag?  w#ite  tb  M^; 
mmhMMAnvi»^^,^fl^J  wiihed  to  1^^ 
•«li«f^sipi^^m«  lolM  OB  Ifi^.  WMto^fifoeard  the 
Pfrtilcate  of  the  discharge}  wh«ii  he  informed  ine  he  had  wnt 


m 


'iJ:'^'  k^ . 


.«•■•■ 


m 


pi'f^^'wm 


/    1 


(»'•; 

^4-- 
^ 


(  ^ 


"1P«- 


24 


your  company  within  one  yew?  ^  *»eWge.  <h»i» 


eral. 


r 


Capt  Jacob  Peabody,  comrniS^Tti;  *^  ^  - 
ery,  being  duly  .worn,  wa.  ini^  'f  '  T^^  ''  ^rt«- 

teer  companies?  ^  «'"*  '^••«**^,%f,T«Im,. 

•"O  ..w  bi„  ,  ,^M  „'  j^lS?- ««**  » C  *^ 

wilt.,  ««,rdi„gly,  ^,^j  ..X^kT        ."^  "•  *W- 
•"■•■W!.    1  told  iu«  ,„  JS_!"  **^''«*  *''>5« <». 

:,""  "iSm  ■•"  "»tod  „,  jl'l"'  '«v«...  (M- 


"^teaecoHingiy.    l| 
<or  a  diwluu^l 

wiA  Geo. 

diaeliarget  ih«» 

»ite,  Md  iViiot 
5ted(oOen.Good- 

»  «ptheii(ie£(^ 

■n^ny  of  Artil- 
anaweredatfoK 


If aj.  Joaeph 
i*.  being  dttly^ 

■.sS*i-.".*'i!!>  •#■ 


i^^ 


15 

lite  Brig.  Majdrlkf 
%as  interrogated,  and 


the.4%a(i 


Good. 

,,^,%.  jtr«^^ 
**  *'  two  jnH- 

nd  w^e^.«iih 

'*^eB.Go^- 
'*rged.|BiBgt 


~vl 


■'.5'^. ' 


Afe-vfi, 


[.;  i%^ X4I.    Bid  Gen.  Ooodale  evcji 
(iiieDiilgei  o^  privates  in  volunteer 
J.  I  have  al#ays  made  it  a  rule  to  eoiita|t  hiat^fi  ^tliat 
bjeet;  b^lfWill  not  say,  (io|Mi«faurge8  have  not  >^g^W 

eC^Hrnn' 


d  without  nil  Ming  eontulteCHf  never  gave  me  ^y  written 

rder,  and  I  do  not  reeolleet  any  fg/aaenX  verbal  order  for  that 

^e;  bnt'sometimea  tie  has  negteeted  to  hear  the  whole  eir- 

•taaeeg,  but  said,  grant  them,  and  there  will  be  no  dilB- 

lift  By  amrt.  Was  Ojen.  Goodale  ever  present  with  yon 
[when  diseharges  were  granted^*"      ^  ,   •  "7       ;i|. 

.4.  I  do  not' reeolleet  that  he  e^C  was.  ^ 

j^.  By  J.  M.  Did  you  not  aeknQwledge  befbre  JoMph  E. 
iHBpragne,  Esq.  thatjrou  had  a  general  order  to  diseharge  pri- 

i^***^'   .,.^.^;.  ,./..,.._  •,.    ^       #fct!i^;-^!-:>  :-• 

J.  I  said  I  had  a  general  order,  but  X  alAuled  to  an  qr>* 
I  der  in  Febi^ary  1811,  when  Gien.  Goodale  was  going  an  a  jon'r- 
I  ney;  and  I  never  had  oeeasion  t<>  aet  under  that  order.    The 
•Her  was  never  recorded;  I  eoiMdered  it  of  no  eon^equenee; 
aji|  it  is  now  mislaid,  orH^^' 
*Q.  By  court.    Was  JOttt  oker  ever  eonntermiuided? 
V^.9.  No;  it  never  was. 

■*'-4l.  By  deft.    At  what  time,  fbr  what  pnrpos^[|«id^i|!|  what 
tension  i^as  the  bfder  yon  relbri(^  given^  ^ 

^i-'^   I  think  it  was  in  f1^'.  1811,  aii4  for  the|A|rpose  of 
traAti|i|^iidinary  busing  of  ttielligade  dtti|ig  hit  ah. 
Mii^d|pll^1^i|llitof  his  li&^  '^' 


^»iri<r 


the  fhflier  yon 


ived  lii 


toGenl 


(Mffia^tftli^eeP' 

4. 4d^ot  ieenn^  disttietly^iint  1 1^  ^^  oat. 

..^4*««i^^ .  jH^^  ever  ■  hiire  HMwiit^;9rdei<  from 


^er««ai|Miti^?/ 


i*^Sm 


-„«>  ilfej>*i*if.i(#'-:?>  ■*>«**>*■■-■■*  r;;i*--J 


y4*»- 


*Wf^Hi^4i^tt  ne  verbal  orders  onlyJ 


Jr, 


m 


1.114.V 


jLlSt. 


:.*. 


"S^.    'AL 


¥/ 


^M'-'^'W-W 


•«,« 


m 


^  *  'IF 

-o'^befbn,  tie  counf      f  ji**1Se»  «  the  Ifigide  BooI 

,    ^' Byaaim.    To  wfcnn.  /^  1 

tibaraenffi.  ^°»'n  were  tfce  mw"*/:    ^..--^    . 

«'e»edi,ejj.-_ .   .     °®'  «»  tfce  company   ft.«».      .         "**' 

,    *  ^y  coarf.    Wan  «»»  /.     .         «*oodaIe,  or  not      * 
otthe  diri.i*„     r   iJ^       ?*  pewons  who- fci.-  *««      -?     ' 


.1  '  ) 


.A;, '..4 


'^, 


.\i 


11 


■^  gee  if  we  w«ii|i8eharsed  tromti^^  C«det  eoaXij,  Jn 
he  had  givin  Sfoj.  White  ordeni  to  disdiarteiS  Wi- » 


*'"""^''m**'-*^«« 


«e|e«rteiW  the  d|i 
•*E.Spnigne,Bg^.^e 

l^e  then,  f  the  p^^, 

V,  from   which   thej 
"  »»  Capt  Bow&tch. 
■«fl"««ti7  cali  en  voa 
»"' the,e  di,eharJe> 

-Jted  abont  He  ap- 
wons  referred  ti  by 

n>e  about  a  dr^. 

'»'Wrged,bDtIdo 
aale,  or  oot.     * 

'ted  about  the  Id, 

"L!?'» '  «^dt 

fit  an 

for 
■^e  wmoired  Oat 


^•le  iay  abdnt 


at  the  request  of  any  commanding  •i^iferfy|,^pa»y, 
repcati^  it  aereral  times.  - 'Iff       ^-- 

'.BbenelMr-Wdreester  wa«  again  eaftl^-''-'^^'^'''^^%.^ 

latiSeWd  authorized  M#«rtriiH,^Sdi^arge  p^,^ 
olndteer  eompaniea? 

f  ;  I?  ^*^  *•'»  ■»*'*  '•  M  giren  jjoh  oid^  and  had  direct- 
MMverdI  privates,  who  called  on^im  f^r  dUohw-gea,  to  Iklaj. 
wife,  for  he  attend^  to  thoae  mattere,'  and  Gen.  QoQdal* 
tedHed  to  the  aame,     , 

t^  Gep.  Goodie  atated,  in  the  trial  ^foreJ^tJ.  Sprague  Baq. 
th^  he  had  giV^  apthbri^  to  Mig.  White  to  diaehftrice  nri- 

A  Ye»,  anp  I  think  Mr.  Sprague  m^uat  be  miataken.'       - 
>th  Chpi^   Robert  iMntouI  Eaq.'hehw  duly  awo^,  waa 

»i«em»gated^|n4anawe^«ii»H^  ■■V;^ -^    ;;     '/^    ' 

Gen.  Goody's  eoodoet  iii  withholding  a  reqi^it  jfefc  the  dii* 
charge  of  ^1.  Lovett  of  t|«  £mt  Brigade  and  ite^ond'ljiviaio'n? 
,  •*•  <^^  V^e"  h^^^  be^ft  deranged  in  mind  Hnee  Decembei' 
laati  hatri^  ain^e  lucid  interTaiaj  on  the  4th  of  April  laat, 
haring  ^  jn^  U|terv|l,^^eMled  on  laj  J^^  me  jibout 

proeurlnghia  due^rge.  Ah  applieatf^  fo«'4at  purpoae  waa 
made  «n|^Jligned  by  him,  «nd  left  with  me.^  Pn  t^e  rth  of 
April  I  delivered  thfe  aume  requeat  to  G^b.  Gb<^ale^  Md  in- 
form^ him  of  Cot  ioT^a  situation,  and  rtiuea^ted  hiiiii  to  ap- 
ptm  <.tl||»  applie^tif^  which  he,e«n««9»*|^;Wi  and  immedi- 
9Ufy  aigued  it,  I  thfios  emaulted  hipi  mlxMit  forwarding  the 
**r  *  ^  A?«uUitf>General'a  oftlee,  whe»|,|s^g^ Jie,,i,ouId 
toA  hfiu  S«»N,  wouid  aeft»fjy-,  yfT^tt,  and  have  it  forward 

**'**^^l^,>t>  till  tj^e  eonteated  deetion  of  Bilgadier  Oen- 
er«r  wi*  gjftttled.    BoBHitine  afterWai4»  I  >rM  informed,  it  had 

3  1 


■.  ••'fli 


«b; 


•A.'.'/- 


v 


.-.  a!/ 


^mm^Mt^i^y:'k. 


'^>^^r 


■■■* 


# 


7- 

•y, 


If 


# 


-•tbe.«fotwarde^.,d  .ailed  on  Gen.  GoodiUe,  the  mot 
■^Bp,  tod  be  informed  me  he  had  not  %r^AiXi<i  aiwlTAs-  • 

'  ^^^l*  -  ^'"'  '*  *°  """'  *^*  ^  ""Rh'*  '»>^»n»  it  iiid  pH: 
,  '^Wf^^^r^''  refuHcd  to  deliver  it  to  me,  and  Nud 
'  »t  -Wdl^t  go  o#f  hi.  hand.,  till  the^  wm  4^rig.  dfe- 
erd  eleeted  in  th.T|j^e.  Wtime  in  June*!  Je/aUh. 
A^mt^t  General'. -olllee.  to  inquire  if  Col.  Lovett  wa,  di.- 
charged,  and  fonnd^e  winirtj  I*  the  Adjutant  «i3u  in- 
formed  mg,  that  he  wa.  inrtructed  to  make  out  the  discharge.  J 
The  ap^hc^tioB|fea«^^  K^eerived  in  tlie  Aiyutint  Gen-  1 
era|^ .  office  en  the  sth  or  9tl  ttf  June.  '   ~  *  ^t*-="»^  -^  -j^,  ^=» 

%.  ByXM.    Haafcoi'UTettfceii  de^ged  t«iii8t£lUy 
since  (he  rth  of  A|»ril  la4t?  '  4 

«.  ^!fsme:i$i&%wMh,  u.e  any  Areatening  1w|L 
guage  toward,  any  ajt  the  electon  of  Bfig.  General?  *•  ^ 

^.  After  I  had  intimated  to  him,  that  I  .hould  make  i^ip- 
m^tatim.  of  hi.  eonduet,  if  he  di4  not  f,rwa,4|j^  applii 
V^y.  *«  •nwharg,  of  Qol.  lK.Tett,;he  fl^JS  isSt  Jia 
.houW  be  obliged  U^U^n^^tiJia^^o^^ 
•de,  for  their  eonduitat^the  former  election  of  Bife.  GenerS. 

ti.  ?*  ?*^'^J^^''*°y«"'*«"*PJ»»'edtoGen.$oodaIe<br 
the  di.eharge  rf  Col.  Uvett,  did  he  pronMse  ta  fort^  th»  kn 

^.'Vevaiiie^^rtaleii:'::    ;^;f  */'«' •■:'--^'^:    ■'^  • 
q.By  Sofn*:tm]^p^  ifteii^er  of  the  deetion. 
of  Brig.  General? 

AathinkhedMittt^dihefiisteleelioi;.     ''I'^    ? 

Here  wa.  produced  a*d  nead  to  the  cbi^t, »  certified  eMr 
rfthe  proceeding.  Wlativeto:thefir.t  eleotlon  of  Brig.  G^n- 
«ral,  being  marked  No.  8,  and  annned  to  the  pn;eMding«, 

?t|PM«:fije'  ^.  Jo«eph  Stea^ii,,  Ute  eoihrnaader  of *a 
com^^  of  mUitii  in  the  5th  Reg.  i.t  Brig,  ad  Ur,  beiMln. 
ly  .worn,  wi^nt^gatc^,  and  answered  kg  |bUo#^^#*^ 

yoa>  sign  «» «liilgittiott  to  support  Mi^i;  Bfiiah  Flint  il.  CoL 


'■'^^^^f'^y^1^^^^'''-^f^y ,;  w"  '■fm 


i^-h- •'■■■"•- 


1« 


oltheeleetioos 


I  ot1^«  laid  0tk  1U|.  a*  eoalhti^n  h»  ««ald  f«te  ftl^  ^'H^ 
^l||ite'amHBrig.€iener«I?  <' 

^Kcire  Gen.  Goodale  handed  the  ebait  a  joi^^'fn^ 

fUl«wa,Tiz.-  /--■  .-' '  ■^.■' ^>*  *■! 


**Beneral  Comrt-Jtrariid,  8<riem,  tfyimber  99th,  4M9. 

<<Ceina»onwealth  vs.  Bhenezer  Goodkle,  Mi)j.  Qen.  j||BiT. 
.^  i«MM«i«Miitt«  militi*.         V       ^ 

<*The  Defendant  objeets  to  the  admiuion  and  heai^g  of 
<*aa7  tettniony  in  tha  trial  of  thia  eaBe*  whieh  may  re^e  U> 
■*^y  eonTenatioB)  any  deelaication,  or  aet,  had,  perform  A  or 
<«expre8aed  by  him,  at  any  time  when  he  was  not  exereinng 
<Hhe  authority  of  his  station  as  Maj.  General,  or  acting  cffi^ 
^<flially  as  an  oiBeer  in  the  Maasaehnsetti  militia.     ' 

«*8igned,  %     EBENEZER  GOODALf.'* 

■''.?,  .-'■       .'■    ■        .  ■  ■    ^. 

The  original,  being  mariced  No.  9,  is  annexed  to  the|iro» 

ceedings.  ;,^./' ■-  ';;^"i|,y:i/i^.;,         ,4.;    ..     "...         |' 

'Hereupon  the  court  was  ordered  to  be  eleared  of  spaeta- 
torij  Which  wak  done  by  thoMarshaL  After  eon8al||||bn 
the>  doors  were  ordered  to  be  opened,  and  t)M|Judge  Adf^oeate 
was  aidvised  to  inform  Gen.  Gaodale,  that  wftvourt  *|eonsid- 
**ir,  a«l  an  oOieer  it  i$i^piMisible.for  «t^i(^i^M^9^  d^lar- 
<*atioa,  or  ajil^  had,  performed,  or  expd^d  t^  him)  relating 
"to  the  militia,  at  any  time  while  in^nkmission,  and  that  in 
"so  doing  he  exercises  the  anthori^i|f  hit  station.  They 
"thereibre  determine  that  itis  expe^it  to  examine  the  wit- 
«ness  olfered.»       .'.    vV.-       ^     §'^^' S     r.- ^M'-'^ --' 

Ii|imediately  after  this  deterqphiatioB  of  the  eonrt  was 
lii^Uibwn  to  Gen.  (I^|«j»di4ai^  A«  handed  to  the  Judge  Advo. 
eatojKj^er  writtMffjM  feUowS||  which  f«a  read  to  the  court, 

TifcSE'.  r     ,    '   -     ■■■>'     '-'■■    '    ■  '■     -I    *■..,  :■ 

'  1^  ^«^ip^  Cimrt-MiHi^8al»m,  SepUmber  nth,  laii. 

#CliifliaM|iwealth  ts.  f^kplief  Goodale,  M*!.  Geo.  ai  bir. 

y  .|i|iil|prtta '  BtfBtia.  ^:W.':riv%--- ' 

ndant  deeliB^s  fbrdier  to  aanwer  te  <tha  aixth 
^•peeiieatioa   af  charge   exhibited  agaiut   him,   because 


'■*.K 

•-ijj  ..«5;'?ji 


-i*^ 


I 


'^i 


■.Tit-;»-A*"  -'"Ngi.' tM^"^ ' 


t:m 


■.'■^.■•ft-s,,. 


!l*-*^- 


'W^z 


.* 


J6 

•*^e  court  w«^  k  * 

■^«»"  to  the  «anie.«  ^•**'^* '^  wqnuwl  fa,^.       I 

•»  bein^  called,  m,„re«d.  iS."  '°"P'f^*'f  *id  defe,di»r 


donelbi 

The      

•«*»  *U  uuirered  ,„  „ 
M|HMna,ei%r^,  on  5ei 


LgJ»fdoftBepro, 


•n  being  cabled,  ^.^^^^ 


M 


m 


y^jii^'-'i-    ■- 


*Av-<dS51. 


lAi 


"4 


je»*ipI«i««|.of,| 
T  Md  furmkUj  ml 

KB  OOObALB.'* 

s 

annexed  (,  th.^ 
fint  eUwe  jo  th« 

'eared  of  i^t2^ 

^aiid1|fiBj„jg^ 

"•at-^«n,eci,Brt 

r«««aaflilljr«id 
tf»  a»  (be  natar* 

'«»•     Tltey  aji^ 

wqairedtuM. 


"-;■■■•,  i''  ?t  ^ 

'  ^Saitbn,  ^ 
'f^'  llionuu 

waidotiei^ 
d  ilelbndtef^ 


^\ 


.2t 

paper,  writtea  ia  tfiet*  word8,«^^^^e,  eflkiM^af j|lu>  flk 

|<*SS|;.  p^M^  oar  taered  hopors  to  8tip^[;Himal||plM:^'p70* 

|*<i4ded  he  aet$  hia  oum  opinion  in  the  choice  of  a  9ii^  tftMpf^ 

\*i3ir  an'  requested  ne  to  aiga  it,  whiel^I.did*    ^itt  ,i«aa  ,^arf) 

adnitted  hj  Gen.  Ooodale,  |h«t'  the  We|^ing  is  a  (me  oi^| 

'  of  ttie  paper  presented  to  MAJ.  8^arna.3    It  told  him,  I  ealiAi* 

land  to  vote  for  Maj.  Vliat^^f  tliere  was  an  opportanitj)  he 

•aid  he  did  not  doubt  it,  but  he  wished  to  eonvinea.Maj.Ilint ' 

fa|B  wodd  ll*  tapperted^  Ibr.i^'naoiber  of  penant  had  been  to 

hui^  to  e^Bvinee  him,  ilc  0ol.  Putnam,  w|ito  then  eommaafld 

the  0th  Reg.  should  be  promoted,  he  ,  would  be  superseded. 

Hie  said  Capt.  Jonathan  IngersoU  and  others  had  told  Maj.  ^ 

Flint  there  was  a  detemiiiiatipg'SjftE^  oflle^rs  in  the  MEKeg. 

*to  snpersa^  hitn,iand  he  only  wfu|ted  the  ^aper  to  eoorfaea 

him  thiere  was  ao  swsh  determination,  or  combination  to  super- 

sede  him. .  C  ^' 

O.  Sk  Mpe.  Was  th?re  any  other,  paper  sh^vn  you  ta 
sign,  and  where  18  the  onnnal?  "^^  ^     ..^ 

«l.  I  never  saw  any  other  paper.  IThe  original  IMW.IR- 
stroyed  by  Gen.  Goodale  i^fker  tiie'OoBrt  of  Inqidry  ^»s  or- 
dered on  liim,  and  a  fbw  days  befWre  the  Coart  was  kaldeis. 

%  By  eouii.  Did  Gen.  Gopdale  girt  |Mif  teaMOk  Ibr  de- 
st^yi^g^thf^oijctfial  paper?    '  ,.,^-;jt".  ,   •',:.-. 

,ji|f.^|^}  1^1  reqaested  him  to  tear  off  my  mubi^  and  h%  ; 
destr^yi^'tl^  ftiftx.    There  were.theasliaf^liKren  signa> 
tfltfos.tQ.the.papeiy^'     .<..fX>  v -^  :'.'<..^,\.-X-  ':,.:■■    .    • 

q,.  Ji^f.  Jd.  WasMiy,  Flint  eleeted  Cobnel  after  Col. 
Pa^^fai.p!^moted?  » 

..  .y,^||||il||p|t|,.was  SI 
tie  paper  tolelPlbr 

li|JidMl#  Pattae^^lato  ««^muuiAiirV««^^    ia 

f-ib4f~imwnii,-  mm-  iatarrogj||||giM^IUIowt. 
IH4.G<nii<fi»<Nbi*'r«qMttp|||^^  anp 
Pf||ir>  •■pjMTt  M^.  Flint,  provided  ha  woaIi.y««pbr  C9I. 

^,  pe  shew  po  a  papei^  ia  the  market  in  Sale«N  on  Sat- 


ed} bat  I  believe, 


ho  signed 


/ 


7  f 


3%^- 


^ .  • 


':^ 


« 


«•«•  if*.  -JTrJ;  6  yt"^'  '^"^  Ife 


*jJftJ,Sfi,  ■1**4, 


■%^ 


"^M'\ 


'■•Pi 


4. 

■V 


523 


•>dto|jrf.eneejB 


fr'lJ'^Mlii 


W' 


I 


Be  Kit  fpri;;*^, 

Bri|{ildier^I. 

Jwcn  to  Miy-. 

•^i  there  irw  n 

%  «m4e»teed 


»WttI4rote 


'd.  On  Boiulayiooruiug,  Ihoday  before  the  jbMIUvb  ai  Brtg*' 

dlineral  in  May,  Orn.  Ooodale  eaned  oik  «t»  Aod^iiSflf 

!f»pt.  lugenoU  and^otheri  had  be**  to  Mij.  Flint  to  ial* 

KiBTbelkvi/  it  WM  agreed  amoiig  the  b^fcert  rf  tke  "tljjlj^ 

|(^  lupersed^liifif^prpTidedl  there  ahoojid'  be  a  yw«w  w'^ii^^ 

laper,  linilar  to  the  on«  refeitaS  ta  ^ 
J,  ind  said  he  onlly  w^i^H  to  eonrii^ 
BO  auek  agreement  amoac  toe  bflteiellf 

"By^SSu  .Had  he  any  •*|e^  1»«^«"  '^J^Jj^ 
,,/or  did  h«  wmeioWy  ftriKatpiirp«if?*"7^ 
ii:  I  d(i  ifct  reeoHeet  thit  he  liad  atoy  «|thW  hi>«ln«M,^ 
tiL  Aea  Tapley  of  the  «th  Beg.  beiBg  duly /•wow,  teltil- 

Nipper,  ohligating  yoaraelf  to  rote  for  MiJ.  iPlinl  for  Colblffel, 
ifhojfottld  Vffte  for  CoL  Dayid  Putnam  a^BrigadiorOeneiral? 
A  On  Saturday  moriiing  preteding  the  eleetion  hi  Brfga- 
dief  Geiier»*,**e  handed  me^  a  jAjigr  fo  iigli,  iinHlir  to  Ae 
6ne  pentioned  in  MiJ.  Bt^rtb»  terthplWfy,  "^d  ■«! d^^  riai|ht 
•ig^'it,  if  1  pteaMd.     I  adted  him  the  Wi  of  thai  pft]i«ri^^ 
■aid  Captl  IttgendU  ami  6thert  had  heeii  t»  M^j.  Wini  to  p»^- 
iAile  hiili  if  Col.  Piltnam  ihiuld  he  ehoteu  BrigidirtP  OMe. 
ral,th«effieen  of  tha«h  Beg.  had^  eomWued  to  ■n^enedo 
hiijf,  thai  he  only  wanted  to  etlUTinM  him  ^^ra  wa»  i»  wrtn- 
biimAton,  i^'iii^lt.^-^*»^'^.f^W'**^*^^#*'**^^^ 
?jll/'JE^  *W»*r  ;  Wao  this  eonthinaUon  against  M*j.  ViliBt  in 
MiB«^ae4«e  of  hfa  Tothig  for  doLPatkiam  i^the  fi»mer  elee- 

id  yon  ev«r  hea?  «f  tibii  •ombinatioB  t*  M- 
pentde  Bttij.  Flin^eept  from  Gen.  Cbodale?,^    ' 

'  'r?A^Y9»,f,hvri«j^pte9UMi  to  tiie  eleetion  |  he*id4tf  aiefa 
>|iyii^irttiiin  bnf  Mttiitf^i^lleot  fli»ir  %hoiik  f^' 

^'^"By  same* ,  Miw  wwy^iMMiM  ware  nn  tilia,«»««..»*wi 


*•,  -si 


-"i! ' 


vi?i|»'iW<» 


">, 


•*«* 


\    v^ 


^ 


p>  ■  r 


n 


■■»»  • 


-•IS". 


U 


;^ 


^o" wAB,*..  ''IT'S*'' "T'l-fes.  i».„.....5A 

•I  .   J  "  ""t»«m,-  ami  ~jj  .     °  •"*"»«1«  Wn,  if  i»  ij 


^f; 


"^'As'  *•* 


'«i.a'^^.i 


•j^  : 


•4'"''       'fi 


,'J*A.a/ 


J  .. 


r^ 


'•5^»««»«ii 


fit*         '^  *^'v-^He^«^     B^'-' 

^l»*l«r  lifter  ili', 


°^  albr  (^ 
**%  iferwer 


'25 

Btf  J.  M.    Wliiil  do  70a  kniw  of  Gea.  Oood«le'«  faM 

in  the  eleetioh  of  Brig.  Ofeneral  in  May  \i»ti 
Abodt  the  fifteenU|(  or  sixteenth  of  April  kst,  I  wis  at 
Gkiodale't  holUe  at  his  retom  firom  Saiem,  when  he  Mt^ 
» h»d  been  t«  take  depositions  abtfttt  the  eleetion  of  Brigadi^ 
Bfal.    I  inquired  how  he  sneeeeded,  and  he  said  verj  veil* 
fvi^aired  if  he  was  likely  to  obtain  a  eommission  for  (Sen. 
itnau;  and  he  said  he  should  hfty^  it*  that  he  was  going  to, 
f Boston  tomoifoW)  and  thatitlptf  solely  with  Mm.    I  said  I 
I thooght  it  lay  with  the  Qoyemoi^*  and  he  then  fiud  he  did  im^ 
Iveaa  so,  but  he  nkeant  to  use  all  his  infltteneef  and  should  ge$ 
the  eommission  tomorrow.     Afterwards,  in  Jnly,  he  was  al 
•ar  lu),Q8e,  and  said  he  had  l^vored  Cot  Putnam's  eleeti^n*^ 
'  :^By  some.    Bid  Oen.  Goedale  threaten,  to  arrfit  aii^* 
offieers  in  the  Iffigade?       "  i;    ,  ',^,ti,/.j, 

4.  Nof  but  he  skid  some  of  the  oflieers  tveal^  hfia  Veij 
nnhandsomely,  and- he  had  a  good  ipind  to  arrest  tham.  t 
think  he  naitted^a  Mr.  L^^on  of  Beferiy,  a  Qiuw^i^l|asjt4^ 
of  a  regimnit,  who  aeted  iui  Adjutant  td;C4^.I^^ 
Bting  orders  Ibr  the  first  eleetion  of  Bl^j^er  .Geoeriil. ,  .; 
Capt.  E.  Vif,  Hint  of  the  5th  Beg.  being  duly  sworn,  testis 
Bed  as  fol){i>ws. 

^.  By  J.  M.  Did  Geq.  Goodale  request  yon^to  sign  any 
paper  to  obligate  yptirself  to  si^p^rtlfi^.  Flint  Ibr  Colonel, 
provided  he  would  vote  Ibr  Col.  David  Futaam  for  Brigadier 
General?  ^ 

J.,  On  Saturday  preeedipg  the  eleetion  of  Brigadier  Gen- 
eral  hetiaqiKsted  me  to  sign  a  paper,  written  m  nearly  thes* 
wordsfr^*<We,  the  oifieers  of  the  0th  Reg.  do  pledge  our  words 
«and  saered  honors  to  support  Miy.  Elyah  Flint  for  Cobnel* 
"provide  he  will  vote  for  Cot  David  Putnam  for  Brigadier 
'  <Kjbaera)l?'  There  were  no  names  on  the  paper.  Alterwardt 
he  ihew  me  the  other  paper,  referred  to  by  the  other  witnesses,  . 
witt;|it  or  seven  of  ^e  names  of  the  officers  of  the  0th  Re^ 
01^  Tb.  Capt.  Stearns,  Capt.  Pettee^  Capt.  Piitnam,  CainU 

,  ^#  The  Ute  Got.  Girryi  who  ii  referred  to  whererer  the  exprndoa 
0SM7W  is  uaed  in  theie  testimofiMh  ^ 


% 


ti 


m 


J 


#■ 


^i# 


.0'*-4i 


vifc 


#^ 


i?6' 


*'«  on  the  A.,     ,      ^  *""''«««ion  lb- J  ^«»tiiain.»» 


1*- 

■'*^fefe 

'.,._* 

ii 

Aku'..,Aw 

® 


27 


%    ■ 


[id  hin^  1  should  be  ashamed  oftt.    Gen.  OOT*Je  .aidji 
it  be  kept  8ce«i|  ^.>^lHvit- ..S.-f  ;;#  •• 

I  By  /.  M.    Did  not  Gen.  Goedafe  tell  y?m,  Ui^  «f  ||« 
nee  o*Col.  Hovey'i  fmnd.,  he  ei^rewed  Wa^  A||t* 
Me  to-IiiB  election?  ^     ^^-A'  '   v- -        ,'  '■         *;'^' 

J.  Ye«;  bnt  he  said  he  wiii  «letenili<e«  *l«*  Cdl.  H»^ 
kwdd  not  b<S  elected.  Thw  wa»  after  the^firtt*, fji4^M 
b  gecond  eleetion.  '■-. -  '■-"  "^■''  ■  ''"''*^' ' ■  ■^- ^^-  ^-|j^^ '  ' 

^.  By  same.  Did  Gen.  Goodale  tcU  yon,  that  if  CoU  Hov- 
[ey*»  friends  were  not  at  the  poll,  on  the  flffth  of  i&^t^ 
'fhbiild  cIo«e  it  immediately?  %^   > 

4  A  He  said  if  Col.  HoTey»«  fiiendt  were  not4he«,«e 
I'iilnld  elose  the  poll  in  four  minute*  from  the  time  »ppointed 
Ijk  the  election,  and  they  might  help  them«elve.  if  they  cfiuld. 
q.  By  defi.    At  what  Ume  wa»  the  paper  handed  to  yon 

f  your  signature?  " 

J.  I  think  on  Friday  or,  Saturday  befota  the  ele«t^on  of 
Brig.  General}  and  the  second  paper,  having  the  .ignatiwes, 
vaa  shewn  to  me  on  Saturday  preceding  the  Court  <^^qwry 
on  Giin.  Goodale.     ■  -   .  . 

q,  By  same.  What  did  yon  mean,  by  saying  you  would 
not  sell  your  vote;  was  any  bribe  offered? 

A  I  meant  I  would  not  obligate  myself  to  vote  for  any 
body,  and  wbuld  not  sign  that  paper. 

Col.  Jedtto  Putnam,  being  d^ly  sworn,  tesUfied  as  follows. 
q.  By  J.  M.    Have  you  ever  had  any  eonversatiw  with 
Gen.  Goodale  about  the  election  of  Brig.  General? 

A  On  the  2«thof  May  last,  the  day  after  the  eleetion. 
Gen.  Goidile  said,  the  electi«Mi  was  made,  and  Col.  Dav.d 
Putnam  was  chosen.  He  said  he  rode  from  the  place  of  dec 
tion  to  the  State-house  in  Boston  in  less  than  an  hour  and  an 
hilf.  The  distance  ismore  than  fifteen  miks.  He  also  said, 
i>»  had  exerted  himself  as  much  to  save  Gen.  Putnam's  dec 
a«kB,«»  he  should  fifhii  own  salvation.  ^ 

David  Wilkins,  being  duly  sworn,  testified  as  follows. 
'q,  ByJ.M.   Please  to  relate  what  you  heard  Gen,  Good- 


"Hi 


/ 


W^ ' 


r^'" 


r 


i.^r  .,/•  ^■■'-•■■; 


■■•k.^^ 


§;. 


^M^m-^ 


**  ■ 


♦ 


39 


«'e.tioo,  or  .ppoiXtfce  candidate-  t.a.  "the  oldest  in  crnnmiwion,  and  he  .tod 

Tol.  Hovey.    Afle|»ard.,  having  heard  that  0*1..  Ooodile 

exerting  hi.  Mlnee  on  Maj.  FJnt,,!  cijlcd  o1»  .a^^ 

*  ^r^  :i  *_ii  ....:j— «^tli(i»  if  he  was  made 


«  "^d  nobody,  tCl 

^tUie  other.  He«|| 
^'"'''•ion,«re,,.,,.J 
«» "a^atioM.  ' 

'*«''*<»  Ti.it  Gten. 
"••>»'e««Moa  A, 
''•'«-«te», 
"''•««4    ItoW 

P*l»«»"-  He»c. 

*W»  Br^^ 
■•*»en6nil,   J 

Keve  him^, 

tfcere  WM« 

usaneiea  ^ 

■•;    Jtten 
^'•Oiefal, 

'f  trliich 


Kt,  and  told  himThad  f«U  evidence,  that  ,f  k«J"  "^f 

'*  d-pe  of  in  the.  ekctioh  of  Brig.  «--'^' »«:;*f*  !**  "^ 

iecid  Colonel,  but  ,.ould  be  .upended.    I  ^^^  -*  ^"^  ^ 

there  w,.  a  eombinatiSn  atfbng  the  officer,  of  the  flth  Beg- 

tp  .nperwde  him,  fbr  I  never  heard  of  any  .«eh  combination. 

A  By  deft.    Who  wa.  eleeted  Col.  of  the  8th  Regif 

I  I  understood  Maj.  Goodale  re.i5ned  and  wa.  not  a  ean- 

4idate,  ami  Capt.  Gardner  wa.  ^^J^'^^:^^f 
^    q.  Byname.    What  did  you  mean  by  Maj.  Flint  m 
done  in^ieeleetion  of  Brig.  General?  J  >^ 

A  During  the  week  nreeeding  the  election  of  Bng.  Gen- 

^1,  having  had  full  evidence  that  Gen.  ^-^:;'^^^ 

«„ri„s  to  influenee  the  officer,  different  from  what  he  told  me; 

lihereL  I  wa.  convinced  there  wa.  deception  «  h-»H.ttom, 

and  that  Maj.  Flint  would  not  be  .opported.   1  eaUed  o„  Maj. 

FlihU  and  told  him  of  my  impre..ioB..  The,manner  m  which 

I  became  acquainted  with  Gen.  Goodale'.  e«rtio«.,  wa.  from 

common  report  abo%the  .tr^t.  .»  ,      -« 

Maj.  D^iel  Ha7e.,  being  duly  .worn,  tctified  a.  foBow?. 
.  ^.  BiJ.M.  What  eonverwtion  had  yon  withGen.Good- 
»1.  about  the  eleetioB  of  Brigadier  General?  '       ,    ' 

A  Sometime  after  the  ir.t,  and  before  the  .eeond  eleetion, 
we  werc^aUed  on  to  give  depo.ition.  befere  J«tifee  Pdnehard 
««eeming  the  fir.t  eleetion.    Gen.  Goodale  appear«^_to  he  » 
♦  «..ioi»,»iid.a4d  wmeof  the  offieer.  did  not  treat  h,m  well, 
Jinamed  M.y.lMge  and  Maj. Smith.    He  ob.erved  he  had 
formeriy  hew  in  ffeTor  rf  Col.Hovey»but  now  he  ^^J^^^' 
ftkwntopliiion,««d  meant  todoall  he  eould  to  fevor  of  Col.P«t. 
iu.)  aiid  if  the  ofteerf  did  not  tr«tt  him  bitter,  he  wwild  ar- 
rett  theMi$  he  would  Mt  be  abu.ed  by  wy  of  the*.    He  .aid 
He  would  go  and  we  the  Governor,  and  let  him  know  all  aBout 
the  bu.toe«i.    I  told  him  not  to  do  any  thing  which  wa.  not 
n^t,  for  we  .hould  wateh  him.    He  al.o  *^^l^\''^^^ 
•vify  thing  in  hi*  poww  to  effiset  the  eleetwh  of  Col.  P«tnw». 


M*^i||!^ 


vs  ^..'vii:*.  .<*.'  *>»,*'««;.-»-'*ifc.vi'i| 


'■■# 


;■*«? 
> 


30 


<  1^  ou 

'*e  eleeiioT  ^  **  **«*  been  *„  ^^ed  Wn.  I.    ^ 

^'eciion  w-ag  gg*  -„. ,    .    ^^o  to  gee  tu^  «  "'"'  now 

*"  to  10  o'cioplr .  * '''«  eourt  »««        '"S  order. 

«oer  of  voieg  fceini.  *•  ***'•• 


..'/*;'**■  1*1 'Oi'wv 


^•^^^5:^ 


?I?^-M^^ 


•^*WiP* 


M: 


i  '''"t\*' 


..jr„lJ^M!     iB.l.Jttii.»trM  e,l.t«i»t«*.'»« 

I'  in«  duly  8Worn,  testified  as  follows.  _ 

'    Jte^l  tl^  el,ctipn  «f  ^gadier  General  on  the 

;of  May?       ;  .  ^  V       ^  from  Maj.  White,  a.  Aid  de 

officer  of  the  ^'«^^^^t^  CoLLovett,  as  senior 

•*•;.:,. -muk  for  A* 'k""  "'""K**"' ""^^ 

p.«.d..g.  •';»  T^P  *•;,,  rt...  .„  .Vl«k  i.  the 
IT-  *e  »rrf  C«rt^tr...,.nd  a»,  ...d  «  0,.,  h.d 

>,l^!in:,.f  «.e.B^  r.,«e.Udi,  .^d.d*.,«. 


>-,^i. 
»^1^^1 


■if^^m 


^ 


.*•- 


L^f^Ais' 


:* 


■.*^ 


}*'  * 


■  r 


I*.  , 


'*♦ 


'i--  -  V 


.     -r.*- 


•««»<»  0,6  eiec«:      '^'°  ^Aon,  jZ  '"*'"•'  testified  a.  ^n^ 
«»  loth        "^' "  iZn     ''  ^'"•M  to  1      "  "«*«  . 

•?*>;(  .(lie,  i,,..  "'*«'neM  „,^     ""'■»»,  and 


tamed 

[by  the 

fieer  ol 

we  ani 

Ha 

agaiM< 


Sff;'  ■  ^''  .v«ii^\.  *•:■,. 


**■.. .  „,. 


''^flp^^ 


fl 


i\W'' 


-T-^ X- 


*  """'/-Ml 


aj'rece.Vea^ 


I  did 


aetu 


i*ecei 


FCft 


«enio|.  of. 
y^^*^*  «ceord. 

"•^  ordei, 

I 


ued 


our 


'**' officer  of 


*o  •ee  tig 
sitioiurej^ 


«'>«  o«i. 
'"on,  and 
*e;aBdj 
overnor. 


Hymmrt. 
ieh  you  reeeir 
I  received  my  ai 
Lorett  ih  HftNh^ 
"^^hiKidale 
'rdm  Gen. 
e,  requiirii 

(^  tbe  eleetii 

(f.  By  cour^^ 
i  tkal  election 

A  They  we 
ived  of  his 
.Tlie  ballo! 
looik  l  A|i  aeeoi 
tamed  to  the  Ai 
by  the  M^or 
ficer  of  the  Brigi 
we  ondetstood 

Ifajj  John 

q.  J8yJ.  Ji 
against  the  el 

J.  We  a«i 


r  o^aewr 
iera.eoneera: 


ttie  aoune  of  timi 


*' 


tf  first  ele<!ti;»n,*  fl- 
an order  1|ireet  fl 
I  efcctiay  the  next 
to  me  as  senior  o:'" 
^he  militia^  &c. 
!  preside  f^iy  and  im 
iff  May? 
onura^ieHat  that  time, 
ill  the  elec; 


war 


present  except  Col.  Lovett,  who  wi 
,  and  Sfaj.  Fairfield,  whowas  abi 
began  very  soon, 

it  General's  offiee,  as  I  sppbsed,  suj; 
i,  and  witneaieid  Ify  myself,  as  senior 
Gen.  CibodiJe  dissolved  the  me' 
mclte  eould  be  done.  '""^ 
'^l^i^ldled.   t^^'  " 
What  do  yon  know  abodt 
hfMay?-  ".       -. 

that  ^'^^a^t^'^j^ms  tot.ig^.; 
eedingS  of  the  meeting  immediately;    and  we  ^ 
^rsadfon  abdut  the  result,  and  eoneluded  to  for 


**v^ 


iMtraniee,  which  was  done  imm^dtatej, 


i**k 


**> 


^  Jix^  the  Judge  Adroeate  slated  to  th^'e^    , 
doiw  in  behalf  6f 'the  government  was  closed,  ,^/t^^tg^^g^^^^. 

Gen.  Goodale  moved^  tW#iiittp'atf«ff«ri^f«^^ 
phalf,  which  was  granted!     He  then  pii(i|ili|||p|l^> 
stes  ^mDr'8..tt^|Ji|gM#r<W^  <Jlivi!r,wf^lrVit% 
sa4  by  M>e  J«^8«  Advi|pt«tk«  eourt;  the   H|||gii|ii 
'  Bxed  to  the  proee«dings,<^ji|  t|^,4Ul^,«£  -fo^H^j^P/^' 
f  MM  nil Mlilllll   lllflliili«rS 


;^!a 


%.;■ 


i  -4     1 


I  -^- 


*^^^ 


aS 


=T»I5= 


•  fell"- ^'"""''iSEr.'" 


[•V 


"'ft 


'  "u-i 


**?^ij 


^ ^'«'»eJiatej /SE  '  *W« ^attend ^J  ?** 


t'    f 


■f 


• 


^ 


# 


'  -«>«* 


.  r* 


, *^ ■ ^1 


i2S 


'Ml! 


■J"' 


^' 


v.: 


^Wll  IMMt  fo'MMj^^    ''1R(1.  BOt'Oti.'  dtodUl*, 


*»  ««l>l«iD  the 
""^  '^i**  tie,, 


.tsl- 


«3 


pril,  state  to  t&ell^|^riior  tjhil  titaptitoirf^' 
wlkat  nl^i.'flplJbivenatioiiP  ^ 

.i.  I  was  flmieiit  witk  tbe  GflvVerfMir,  (ETeo. 
O(o»iak>,"  i^lwa  €te»>  pMia^ilitfWWi  tf 
kadgi  rei^Best  for  tlie  diMbftrge  of  Col 
jilfeyenior  asked  what  ^the  sita| 
e  both  represented,  that  he  y^m  in 
hnsinesSf  u  he  w«s  deraageA  ni 
idao  disehai^  of  officers  irfttil 
ted,  till  £rter  the  eleetion  of  l^giiHFQlieral,  aaij 
Oen.  Dimiiisoii  aeeoidingly.    This  wa«|PiQM  G6one{KChaiti> 
ten  but  the  Conneit  Were  ao^  prese|Hpp|  (Usiaiess  ^.  ^^ 
Mke  a  representation  of  thi  proeeJmgs  atltttejBrst  eltfiWik 
of  l^rigadier  General,  a>d  »•  J^|S^F*i«»<  _g^.^^^ 
eewin|thai^ection.    -^>.^W^'-;      ■    ^^^gp 

oinfer  ditt  Id  permit  id^e^a^faS^Sehitgyi^ 

^  i^,  hni  ^iiiJ|p  m  ips  «^^  I'^t^ 

thi«p  Mi^  about  tIRlfiMt  it  %S||  have  on  tlfe  af 
eleetioA.    I  do  n<#leM^  t^  Glen.  Goodale  sJiew  the W 
quest  fbr  the  di.^i|e  of  Gbl.  Lovett;  bk'ii$#riili^ir 


with  hint.. 

fl.'VyMm.    %'ii  Gen.  GoodiJe 
wished  the  diseharg^  of  Col;,  LoVett^'   ^ 

^.  No}  bntonlysaidhehadiftieaj 
i^i0^r  i^iaioiii'*'r*""^-  '"'^^' " ""  ^ ' 
W^Mmy^  «H  -^Bi9.4h)^C^rdHii>Mftttiiuid  theititw^ 
iii(.M||  iOrmiW^^^^ c^ert 

^^ih)WI«^«^1»«r|eeUy|th^  sitaiKtioii  #^ 

eitpjrstfi^  order  fsr  tb^eleetion^.of 
the  same  miglit  he  legal. 

'Q.  By  aam^    We!^  th^l^^piPfliiryMi  granted 


s« 


brigade  betwfei 
'Ji»  None; 
•ieetioB,,»iid  thi 


electienl 


^ 


¥ 


'% 


.^•; 


i* 


i 


*^ 


■»^ 


I 


■•3t' 


A 

•omp] 


ran  •jree.M,^,  u(i>.2j  ^*'  ™ 


-I '^'v*  ?■;•■/ 


t^    Vs.- 


-^ 


,    ■♦■■ 


,^ 


.-3 


V^r: 


"j; ' 


_  I  (•  the  curt    TlTwigJW  i«  •»»«»«»  *•  *•"  »'•***" 
1^,  Md  mftrked  ^  liH 
I      AfeflieiMt  <i|l  fl»»^»tion»  •»  **»•  eTidaBee  by  t^ 

|,Tlie  original  to  aii9exe<|p>hepi#edinsHtaiia^wl^  No. 
his.  The  ^iidg*  AAt»6^  then  observed  to  the  eoort,  that  the 
>i^laiBant«  and  defendanfcJiad  dUcuwed  theeyidenee  m  ftO* 
]^  that  it  wa»  unnece8»ary  to  take  ap  the  ttme  of  the><W|irtiK 
a  reeapitulatioii  of  the  it  Hftjl^me*  ap  t^eTidenee,||A 
t0t  and  againit  Gen.  Goodigy,  t*ry  bridly.  «mI  tabmit^fh. 
Mine  to  the  eoort.    .  *^  W 

The  «aurt  was  then  cleared,  and  the  Judge  Advoeate  put 
the  following  quction  to  eaeh  of  the  membert  of  the  ejwrt 
aeparately,  beginning  with  the  lowe»t  in  grade.  ^  r^ 

«From  the  evidence  whieh  has.  been  addvAfboth  for  and 
against  Maj.  Gen.  Ebenezer  Goodale,  and  whaf  he  hai  olBtred 
In  his  deffenee,  are  yo"  •'  •?«•«»  <*»**  *»*  it  gniUy,  or  not 
giiiltv,  of  the  flrrft  article  or  ifiwiflcation  in  the  WP*""*  »' 
Ltjd8l.8|imuelBriniblecom  aiidirfhers  exhibited  |||«t  him?" 
iipf^nrt  deeided,thnt  of  the  first  speeifieation  iTlhai^  iia 
^ddXIoodale  is  not  guilty.    Vw^ri  '      '  ^ 

•  The  question  being  put  in  flie  ttme  form  npon  the  second 
•rtide,  or  speeifieation  of  charge  in  said  complaint^  the  court 
4eeided,  that  of  th?  second  speei^uaUon  of  pharge  in  said 
•OBiplaint,  said'Gocdale  is  guilty.  .^    ^ 

The  qaeaUon  beign  pot  in  the  same  form  upon  the  third 

"  Bification  of  charge  in  said  complaint,  the  court 

"  r  the  third  n^ficatira  of  chsSKHi  m  H^^  eom* 


K^»i»U 


%he;||BeetV>«  bKag  put  in ' 
artieie  Mr  spetiieation  vf  charge 

pI*M«''iMd'.OMRlafo  is.|iMi||'  ;..T.,--*«lrt#*v»ii^i^^^?>»"  - 
'  ''fii'WSi^ijneition  beinjj^^^^Vns  iiu»«v;|w8|p*!ip|il(plpP'*"^ 
^     fntiel*k<spa«ifie»tieMl|||PpiB  Mi4«onip^ 
;  ^f0ti(i^ihn!t  of.  the  imi^ia^  of  Ot^x^  hk^mmvi' 


:  if^> 


^^'•All 


In 


■%. 


m 


i#-' 


«««fea.  #^     "^"^  *»7*  irftlfei,  ^J  7"  <*e  court , 


aitt 


'■5 


d«#=4 


#^ 


■'-*^v 


V-^^f* 


fl^l^--^^^- of  I 
of  CjJ?®^.«^. 


'iber^tii 


Oft 


•'•ie  for 


'''\^t     "^^'^ 


J"* 


, Jm  iilllWI'^iil*  l>«^8  !*"^^  «flubitel  to  the  CommaiiMLi* 
ciiiefb|Lt  Col.  Samuel  Brimbleedmftndothen  of  tbeiWP^ 
diTisimi,  against  M:i^.0eii.  Ebeaezbr4Hodftle  pf  the  gftid,' jivi- 
sioa,  for  diven  ofibnees  against  t)ie  laws  for  regolating;  gor- 
erning,and  diaeipliBing  the  militia  of  thi)e^jft|nmwealth, 
the  Cottmaader  in  Ghief  hM  thoagkfit  to  oWi  M)4  dot|i 
llp-eby  Order,  That  a  General  Coart-Martid  he  aj^pointed 
l|f  the  trial  of  the  said  11;^^  Ebenexer  Ooodale,  upon 
t|B,ehai^i  contained  in  the^il^lpnplaint}  >^J||^^^^|^' 
CtiMiMntl  of  the  state  will  ea^  him  to  be  an^Ki|||||telVM^ 

1  inrirtiund,  mtil  he  ihall  muwcv  to  the  sacid  eompl&intj  and  be 
Otererfamnitted,  oi> Othetwiie  diseharged  aeeoi^n|;  to  law. 
Cottttafartial  will  be  eonstitn^'ailbUows: 


t,,.  - 


'Si- 


endtt  and  4i^  l&t.  lotonel 


litdnT 


<,•'  1^ 


iphik  General  and  one  lAent.  Colonel  Droa  t|i 


^fttothe*tlidirtHfc. 
i4kMtth  ditisi^ 
Plfir^  from  the  7th  divioiOn. 
i  onf  Ltent  Cdton«l  froai  t|a 


tth  division. 


;.4p*N3^*M^^f^^  «^  *■«  "^ 


k* 


.« 


;"L^P«-' 


'• 


'jr 


•  h 


"'*■-■'■  -^"JWitS^-'"^'^ 


•    *^" 


..      * 


.(>, . 


m 


'm 


t 


1^" 


4t>  V 


i 


*» 


fiti'-'4fi 


*^^ 


V   r^ 


W^'^'  '^ 


.  the  ,„pet     ^  '*""• 


'  ?*-» 


f 


■^^f 


M,  2. 


»•     *Bif|lt^t| 


>«^*. 


rojjoiri 


i'Actti^ 


!»««.«.• 


r. 


»«t,  lit 


^j-  Gen  ir*^  *? 


'*n«ij* 


'^^^e  court:  ,^ 


.  »-  o^^^w  'vw«(ri,-4iiait{al,  appiDiBte4  by  the  < 
ae?of  the  loth  of  Aogutt  eor^nt,  to  be  Mdeti.  at 
tMe  aad  day  of  September  n^t^  for  the  trial  of  H^j. 
enlzer  Goodale,  ia  postponed  to  Monday,  t|f  a^  day  ( 
Septenriier,  it  tei^  o'eleek  befoi«i|il^,  du»  4»  h#  holdc 
^jliMi^Iaee  mentio^c^d  in  th^,  aaid  order  fbr  the  pnrpoj 
Imwhereof  all  persons  eoneenM  witt  taJkQ  notice, 
1  tbemsel^  aeeofdingly. 

f^JfSr  order  of  the  ConuMuider  in  Chief» 

DONNIfiOl 


1.^.1 


,|blMM»  who  .halfi  i^Mietail 

'  '  ^    trialnf  libliiii^  and  hairnetiUM  oppo 

ItitherlMk-   Blfn^l'li^lkr  tUr^||p 
oftheai^&MdMhDB  Jie  shiU  be  e«Ile(Nb 

£B£N£ZBB  GQODALB. 


lUUl 


•f 


JJjftiBffrnftfffa. 


Ti|ii 'Mbieribera   eompkvi  of  Sl|>«ieter  Gi^dale)  ,^^ 
Miyor  General  of  tha  8«eond  DiVifion  of  the  MiMi.  of  JIm- 


=»   J 


It, 


i?tH^ 


m 


/. 


■►i 


A 


t 


Y 


S 


■^^^^fWill  aetiniifi.    "!  ^'i^ofi  of  the  miiS-   '  -i^ 


, , "•••w  jMi*        ■'"jA"»«»a  of  the  iii'r#'    ' 


The 


i  «*5' 


•YS 


.» 


^  '- fa 


^■\'i^WTI? 


» 


L^^^ir  l(Ufei««»P«iri»«  P«rt«M  nnder  hi.  eo 
»5t^  **    *« *«1itiVo/|^*S*!*y  proeuring  the  di«eharg« 

et 


'»»!«.  in  Sen. 
eompany,  - -^^^ 


"i»«4'^^*:^ 


if  frwdnlently  aad 

frritftte*  beloogiBg  to 

ieifer  MdTbftDiel  MilUt, 

1o  theiVVWlieijMiidl  by 

)re«steralad  ]!l|ilbt  to  th^ 


his  eompany,  viz.  pbienezer  Wj 
withoot  their  JCMwIedgfe^  and 
giving  the  naiaet  oT  the  saict 

CJ»rl(8  of  the  «ompanie«,^tflnlhe  bounds  of  wlUeh  tfey  ||^ 
•^ctively  reside,  tint  tiley'a^t  be  enrolled  in  fhe  said  oM- 
'^  eompaaies,  andlgpl  to  do  duty  in  the  sane;  air  wliieh  li^ 
done  by  said  ittwAteh  sinee  the  ^nt^^^^^f^j^^d^fixl. 


oiiajJit 

»«»  0^  jpnVate. 
H*l**>panie,, 
''!«•  •nd  i«0. 
^«?5«^inilit^ 


>  .«  6.  The  siu^  Jlivditeh  has  been  guilty  of  negleet  of  dn^; 
famot  instruetii%  His  ebmpany  in  the  compaiiy  exereise'^nd 
evolations,  w|«k  pariaded  bjr  bit  ol^iftr  11^  t|fr^^^^ 
Jiij^,  last  pa«t,^M|  ,/■<;'«'■'=  V  ^^sSiV^-wv^v^if,. *^*i00n-  f- 1^ i::$--^>^ 

ki  hu  reeeiipifpttirClerk  of  his  eonipanyj  without  eoneult- 
ia|  the  otfaei^|||iliis8ioned  dffleers  of  the  said  eompany.' ' 
^•1^8.  Thi^j^ltowditeh Mfi  eieaied  fiUnm  hebiigiikS  to 
"^        .J<M«thaaTiiefcer,  Friluieisff;;Bl|^«rdtiiai^ 
SiiMeon  FistadeM^aJlft  eori^lfim  SUi^^^ 

defieieney  in  their  tqaiptuSaOt  '$t  tw^ 

rwithiv 'the  year^^ew  last  pailf^'^'^''^  ^*^'^-" 

U  Bowditeh  WMguHty  of  innrtlijii^/un'oM. 

egal  eoMdnet,  in  i«eeirid|HN|i|JiQf^pH^s  %^ 

.  a  eompany  training  on  tfie^ibarklkyof  July, 

f  permitting  the  iaid  jpermns,  who  di(^  not  Belong 

By,4o  p»rade  a»i^Tii(Je(  tt^^the  j«id  'm^ 

He  JMldBowditeh^M  been  gdiltjr  of  iiniiiilitiry  and 
^  «^  ^  **•«*  by  making  the'lblb^ng  false  statement,  in  hit 
iiBii^letiilni  of  said  eeibp«iiy  lultfay  last:  ¥k.-^e  re^ni- 
ed  ChriHfVher  Tomer  md  Itaaelfeedl^^  «i  botfljlg' 
eompletely  equipped  according  tp  law,  nrhm  in  Iket  the  saiM^ 
Tuni«r^ said  Jfeedha*  <|!f  Mt  parade  %ith  the  said  eoni-* 
ptt^Mp||their  arms  and"  equipnenti  Were  not  produced  at 
UMHsi^y  inspwaon  on  tthl  ihf  Tuesday  ef  May  last?— 


^ 


r- 


4*  "^  • 


>^#iii 


isr 


.^fir|i 


♦ 


"#■■ 


i 

« 


^   >  ^^erefiire  the  „ 


:if: 


rj^'  tfcat  a  Court  »* 


•*.%»if 


?(^-  Gen*be^  ^JT'^^'^of >frc  res^^H.^^^'^-  ^  *^» 


**i|d 


^^^^ 


i4^J-  .~s 


Mn 


Wing  to  U,v' 

^^gBoiReei'Iitej  ||. 
^■RdcallaCoitrt. 


"tw^-, 


..^ji- 


yf^ 


'*, 


.#^'' 


J, 


# 


*»  rteeeivvd 
*tioaei^«fat- 
*'«*  noiiee 


^    ^       "WBeiai 
*««e»-tiJteeon. 


IllK.tOBpuiiea  olFtlie  wards,  wit|tii(|i||hii^  th/^j|> 
jifterward«^^Nra||^tely,af||^^ 

^^^]mm''^^^  Cap. 

to  be  iMMrgeil)  fni   tluU  ftjlffnmlliiiii 

«^t  said  ebmpali^  training*  ^  Jl 

f^i^klThe'said  Goodde,  botl^aeft'^^ 

iff^vlNfae  Division  and  ^hile^ngidier  jQten^ral,  fas 

Wit  J|li  guilty  of  unnailitary  c||d»c^  by  1llB|a%  j 

ill  authority,  &e.  to  officers  under  him,  partic  ^ 

^  lka?N^j$iTen  hu|  Bri^e  Major  general  oi^n  toj^s- 

;P|l|i«w^ii«f  iiid  others,  from  any  yMnteer  eorps  WwiAn 

^^IliPPPpI^^  any  applieation  of  any  eojumanding  «ffiieer, 

vliMiOltfiiat^Mly  illegal)  thei^by  giving  the  management  api 

:  iSireetioii^if  the  brigadje,  an^  av^n  of  the  division,  to  persons 

who  were  not  at^thorized  by  law  to  perform  th^  patne. 

Vll^^Nfi^ljkir^  has  been  goilt^  of  nhmilitary 

'  aondvet,  uid  of  WjUfolly  injuring  and  oppressing,  persons  under 

A  :his eamapand,  an^  even  depriviiog  the  offieer«i4\the bi^i^etij^e 

light  of  ehoosing  th^ir  grig^Oeiera!,  by  yithholding> 

requert  for  adise^rge  of4NJS||iiltenant  Colonel  within  said 

..hrigade|whp,by  avisitatif|||H|9,  is  deprived  the  ose  of 

;  his  reason,  and  therelqr  f^pu|ii^^|a|S^  any  longer  to  hold  a 

^«|BOiJkmission  as  Lieutenant  Colonel;  and  to  preventing  the  fill« 

»i  &ig  of  an  existing  vaei^ney  in  said  brigade.-r^And, 

jjbv   -  XiM/y.— The  said  Goodale,  in  an  unoffieerlike  manner,  at 

IPtod  before  the  jkte  meetbg.of  the  Field  Offieeri  for  the  elee- 

of  a  Brigadier  Gontral  fbr  the  first  brigade,  interfered  in 

eleetidn,  ^y  undue  and^  improper  inflaenee,  biassed  the 

of  the  electors,  and  used  his  office  as  an  instrument  of 

ing  and  influeneing  the  voters,  so  that,  by  his  eleetij 

|4|Ut|t9dteontrivanees,  ^p^^|||j||ysrading  to 

aiidi||i||M||HH 

ilmi)  and  iiie^^[aenee  thereof  the  senior  offiisec  in 
[e  has  been  superseded,  according  to  the  intent  of' 


■  %;^ 


4A 


*CiAT 


% 
*  if 


'■**' 


» 


A 


'0 

V 


^*T«A W  60OK,  *•"'»»  of  ^*ifei^^^> 


'^' 


-^:rL=^ 


J^BSPKK  Pop,,  **°"' 


^ 


*?> 


"WlLl 


;iv 


♦..  1 


t*  *t 


rtil 

erjr. 

'igaofi 


lri)f  I  mil  will  I'-jiiiP'^jpup. "  I  '^~""'';  ^i 

-11  #^iWiiffi|iit^^  *rTt      ^ . 

ioMeeon  wnC^lers,  t(ie  |aid  Maj.  Opn.  £!bi|nSer  Gtt^ 
f '^  to  |il^  or  ia  «ny  ^jl^gsf*.  MHWr^  heei^ie 
^||P,|i^  tbe  apeeifications  therein 

iij  of  1lirl|^|||jgJ|^per«i{^«^  was 

»«dl  inllpP^  Md  raeiia|>le  to  ft  ti|p  iWEb  (4Beial 

eqn  t^^^fiA  JWJgH  We  J^^  |jjB8tifi«d,  f r  his  pfmno- 

"^  -  ^^Tcntedi  and  tJiereapon  he  prayg  the  jo^ 

1  if  he  8hal|  N  Jbeld  t|^  plead  to  the  said  0^ 

"^^  Tothe<iikh^l^d««%Mgeftti1ird  feoiid^e  for  pl» 

,^T9.th?  mth  aVd  l9((lM%4LPP»*m  th.?  .^i^lKl^iglato 


TMrdiMbodalo,  pMt«a(iag  ^t he  is  sot  hoamd  kj  \m 
lions  «£ikMM4  iiftjyiKi«:diiaMev«|lUfys»t«h,  th««|^ 


-^'■'^f* 


1_, 


.-S^^ 


■,-.  ,     V 

■'  •'■  '^i^ 

f   -m:    .   ^P* 

■i 

M 

•M 

r 

•       ^ 

:m/..   ■ . 

.l^>i;;'" 

-*-- ^ '^i.  mam 

1 

L    m 

Mm..Mm 

<. 

^ 

'■'*;•, 

-■■^'^'■'^":-"-^^''il 

^,1„ -  .  \    '^<». 

k  ;  Ji 

*1 

■  -[--'—-^it^-y^r^^^^ 

•         -.ll 

^'t.  '.■' 

,1 

■», 

t 

V  n 

4 

S^"»" 

y 

• 

• 

J| 

lL 

\ 

^ 

'•' 

-^ 

II- 

■■■'■■; 

*-'        » 

.:^^^- 

/:^:k  ■''  ■ 

•.fi 

.4^ 


/      » 


•^ 


ii&iJ-  ' 


«^P^ 


W'i  ■- 


1*-.<*«:" 


.""I",  PnaJdot.  .3  v7  W*«  III    lIFl'l  I 


t^edutie; 


'••la  court,  and  dp 
Beaanie.         . 

■*pM^iSS5f^  ^^"^  <*^^  BrfiL.  ^ 


V 


&^«^. 


«      % 


4.' 


,.,  T"   •««  CO: 


•#  * 


fjl 


lit       ».  •# 


^SI'^4p?Srf  ■■if'''  *?s''^'^ 


#• 


«?' 


r ' 


"» **§*  Mdl  Gen  On-a  i~  ■  ^^'••"'■■•iKM*^ 


"'jw*p.o<..j;,.;'^t  LISTS' 

order  «f  <liA  rt  ■  "  ■■  '^mf  we. 

^1 1  I™  "•*  ^'•niinajider  in  Cfcjj^  ^^i^-— ^ 


■^#' 


*"|H»«W»re„kJ*'.i.       .  ^     i      ^  ' 


A. 


?l^i.^ 


•W*^. 


#BM,aat  Hiftde  kaMm  to  aay  «f  tJke 


|lM«||Ui^^^^^7  I  ^''''f^if^P^''*"**^*^  pr«y|loas  to  Meh  eleetim  the  elector* 
•  l^^wS^f'^:^!^*  lUnilm^-^Jhf  »«-.r  giro.  {. 

•Juced  by  mfm^lL 

y  T»e  iateiTO|lt, 
"*"eBt,  On  tho 
which  may  h*«^>%^ 
J*  orderi  iMR«^|r 


ipRKk  whvUy  inromal>Dd.tthfgal-Hie|^  ■ 

l|^l  eleet«ir«  Hf  lai  op^ortun^y  of  exereiilqg  th«>  rights  «n^*' 
loil'rdilig  to  Uw^cMstitnUoii  and  lawn  of  the  oooi^  '^' 

i^^AU  wlili^lGIti  aad  aij^atiofp  they  are  rfady 

¥  vJWiBreibra  .y<|M^a«nMrk|isti  retpe«(ftally  refaSb  yoar 
Bxeellen^  to  eaii^e  dae  inmiiihy  to  be  made  in  th»  ^jSibmM, 

'aM  a'lifw  cation,  ormeftink  for  the  lameto  he  had  ieeord- 
ing  t^Kaw,  '^^Alfilas  iifdoijp  bband  wttl^rer  pray,   » 

Anoo  |loy«t>  Ui  mL  Qol  Red  flu.  lit  IfL  f^  D. 


^'■%W"o«o,|^^ 


'"ent,  at  Berry', 

''^^  liHliiWed 
»»iA4irym  to 
whieh  offiee  fca« 

i^FreM«ag. 

^"'••iNw/.ayBd 


TiANiai." 


Kjli 


^s^v.    '^^j^^ 


James  A#i^-AN,ia|iHMli^.'lit  B.  J&  ». 
^  K«fr  Art.        1^- 


re- 


JoHN  RvssELi.,  Mi^m  Seg> 
^**''^i!liljfl!i  hf  Hilu  4he  4ir«goiag  11%  kft  e^p^  of  a 


twdaat  of  flie  ihmJ  iiglhi 


r 


It^ 


n 


mi 


^'Wk  j 


■%v. 


*^-'ai"  M' 


:#f-5 


# 


.'*1 


I\'"  ''SS 


t' 


.r- 


*■ 


-^ 


'41'  ■  ^' 

%f "«v,  for  M  fcii.'tar^!r''L  i"*'  '*'*«»»  to  y 

!:^'«*  prizes,  ^S^^«OTS 
•PpointmeDt  of  .aM  .J  'f""*n«e  «f  a6,»ft.^SZl  •    ^^^ 


*      >♦ 
+ 


itlfesff 


■9^1 


'  "7  office. 


i[n,'t.-:f^yf^i^ 


■r",. 


•JOB  I 

■<;■**■  ^r 

Bam  to 
MS  Ml  I 

tioB»4 
it  oil 
noBif«id 

•  BBWfll 

\    fiJ 


•f^r-"*^ 


3^     ^''      rfl^v^ 


■  •  ^*  ■  -^  ■     ■  ■    ,  ■ 


»iW»T|..fl3^W^T---  ^•- 


mm* 

makev 
.^_„' about 


>t*i^!#Myi 


|Pi»g.'Wi8W.||i|^|i|,.)|»,niyp^|i| 
*^  lMihAirtiJBiild.<lttMi*|^f 


i^9l^(^  Amos  HoTcy 
«•■  I.  it  BrigaJier  Gener.1  WftV  SSMffiffWS^**" 

-  r«f  the  ^--iiiilBlir'^'l  v..^.. .  ,■..,,, 


mhi 


■'«^i^  '^. 


JWi 


'if 


41 


1r. 


'.%-**^      .* 


'-■4^- 


M^i'-^i 


.  ■  ■  "^ 

Lt  Col.  BatM  JMIWttrte 

pi-dered  to  appeal atfe,^tt,^%^£;" 
V,  the  twenty  fiflj»  ifa/of  Mky^xT^'"'^'^' 

•"•H«p*iiaia||PH  wf-"  ~ 

(■■■^'■'      tiv,,.     :"■''     ■---11- •  !  "; 


■■'W'  ■   »»>;•.■■ 


copies  of  the  above')»«ter^ «  foUowwtfli 
ta,  i81«-^eeoria  refii^rt  Aprif^B 
eleet  Celonel,  and  fill  »dfeiai4.^T 


^^^*'  '^^*'^  triM  iui4 


•*;*». 


^■H*'.,  * 


,^^^^ 


■■  ****;ii,  i 


•"■'I 


.^^  *.( 


St' 


-^^» 


** 


-wf.  .t^' 


'vn  ■.  ■>.:j 


,1    •• 


'^^*l:4^'.«. 


Tm, 


"■IPfiZ  r^f 


m 


# 


ttV  -US 


i;'M.' 


O-  -iA** 


m- 


P. 


hmiwM 


•m 


rm: 


'-^^m' 


?*?^' 


57 


# 


'  -r  ''^*?'  *JDaiii6»$f  May  jmL igiit' " 

Oie  ehoice  i|  j^BijgMier  General  to  ffU  >fci>  1|yfc^,,in  tk« 

fi^^BHgft^.tatk«^iM«ndDivMrwk,«e€«iW"*^  "** 

tio«,  th«  l«li  lifteen^  Mid  Brigade  met  at .]  _ 

'*****»»  <^|^^r^  Aa  twenty  fifth  day-of  ll&^i^'^iilr 

9^^^  ^iffWml>^'  A^  meeting  had  been  f^iJArt,  i||> 

Divi«leB^pAOp|,Uieeleetor»  #%r»  tofermSrSttheir' 

wtei  woalA^  ree^vedf  for  the  ad^ymtDou  in  %e  miniites. 

They  were  ««i«lingly  recfeive^rd!p|^^,,%  ao^  .^rt- 

ing,  the  whole  was  found  to  be  eij^teen-Aieeessaiy  tit  ffMfe6 

1*^*"  ten,— Lient.  Col.  Amos  Hwe;^  |iad  nine  Wet,' aid 

XteBt,Col.  QaTid^ufnamj^adnineT|if^/  ^  reas«naUe  tine  ' 

WM  Ihen  allowed  for  the  d^on  to  Droeeed  to  ^e  ieeend 

baUot,  which  produeik  the  «ime  r&ril.?*1fcfc%tK^  and 

fourth  ballot,  the  votei  id  e%e|i  (Mllot  ^iog  i^^m^  v«. 

nine  for  eaeh  eandidate. '  <      *     '       ,  ,    -    -  7 


^^i 


#       By  Older  of  £bcne«i!r  CpSBUei  H^.  Gea. 

;■::' V^-.'^«|»ig»ed,  ^  .JOSBP^W^D^^j|ji|f;  Ald^e-eamp. 

,#<!»•  eop^,  atteit»  ^p,  Cvumm^-mf^^^^  ^w,^, 


^^^^^^^^^mm^im^i  the  'ei^i«.  ;# 

^  irtei:  Daxl|>utnam  to  tf  Bi^MMten^ml  of  the  fint 


*'**««*f^'".'-  'rt'itl.-  f   .»*.^ 


"-■^t,   "  ;(«♦     «  i   .        .^  . 


^^ 


")'•,• 

w 


■■#i 


4 

'«^^- 


■   a 
■*  ''^  ,1 


aJtij»i^jik<t^7 


"tti/tfc*v.. 


^    ..^lYm#' 


-i 


^. 


■s*,.. 


% 


t 


h4 


•  58 

Voo  are  hereby  .rdered  to  anneHi. -#  n 

h  f  r^"  f  *i'"»<r  ftM.1.,  ji^oeiu "  *  ■ 

-» '^^•vwiMiier,  and. that  he  continued  ia  law  k..i»k  jT 

1  mont^H  that  hi-  *om»Iai«t.  tJT^i^^^^''^''- 

*ttin»ii.  «■**•  ^  ""^S*^  *•  •SSitfil*  hi. 


4 


/: 


^  This  may  t6»^^mi^^Ji^i^         *^^ V**" 
minutes  previous  l^iverf  k»  i„-     *"^t      '  ^^"^  ****  »  ^"^ 

pwBii  After  preien1ii«»i»«i{i.^«>  it*i^       «7  <!onffliri«nr 
:  Jfirekt  i"e*»tenienee  W^KS£^^  ??  **  *#- 


.        ,  /        - 


■y  ^... 


'-•■  \ 


'■Mii 


H-'" 


taiba^jU) 


frj'a  (avera  in  Dan. 
May  next,  W  ten  o» 
"S  a  Brigadier  Oen- 

'i.-    ',*'    s*f 

Bow^leh  #a«  io. 

>VA^  JaaUgll 

health  ftr  se^^r. 

•gain  thig  •eason, 

hit 


ta  visit  Cajit. 
rlTo  hadalbir 
»%•    Ifftuna 

y  eoniiifer&f^r 
ii^htpfai||i^r,i 
>r  the  present, 
'^pon  it  <(#ibi 
and'iaiiXftr 


'-'.'*^>-*«'.j«iii%% 


•<f   Y 


fe.f-' 


.,    Hi--'.    '/-^ 


':■»■ 


ir  attended  Oapt.  Eb* 


*     (Copt.) 

.  >*  "•!  ^>  ^  «ij?a_ _„  _.  ^^ 

€^«^Bowaiteh  in  thrfmonti  offieiftember  Jps^at  whiefc 
tyne  he  w«f*ick  with  a^ftV^;  art  eo^e«itdl|;fehiiiiiba. 
forwveral  weA..     Hi.  health  has  of  late  beei,  Imj  infirnu 
and  ha.  often  ineapaeiteted  him  Mm  attending  #  ^•''"•i^  ' 
•ait  a^d  military  eonee^*.  ijj^he  e^nrse  of  the  f^0r.^ 


I  HKKBBT  certify,  that'  the  foregoing  is  a  in^^j^x  9, 
•^cate  w.ne«d  to  the  nroeeetoigs  of  »  Contt^if lli^ 
^  Mj^.  G«in.^,Goodale;^'  ^^f!'^'-^  ^-  «'^a«'*^-  ^^  iH%^^„, 


#*^ 


*  • 


»<>«o»»a.oldier>eon.eien«,.   Kepijt»tio»U4te,|OTi. 
de*rer  than  exirtenee,  whieh  he  will  gaard  with  jeijo«ZttA - 
defe«<lwith  lift.    Good  report  i^  wential,  eonfide^aM.  Titdl 
t<ihii  official  being/   A,oWier».,ehar«eter.honldnotoi%.5 
%,iWi^'^>»«#f%|!«|t  above  tHimputalion.  N^iwoadJ' 

,,and  •«#lii«^|iiji||j^^:|i»e|i^th^^^ 
of  h<.  honor,  and  tnumph  over  error  and  nial.vab«.e»« 


^•SN^«et,'.^th  alae^^TmSk,,  »wm?Erf  3S5 
0Ub^9imnMui  of  t||ir  4*«ty,ijplii«^ii^^amk^ 


■# 


• 


►^•R 


• 

■  '^■fwi'  y  ■"' 

vita 
'la 

^ 

" 

'■  . 

- 

4     '^'i3 

-    *" 

« 

31 

'  ^^!w  " 

\ 

-J 

ft 

-*    *  " 

*    ■":v."^^talj 

1 

P 

"  „  J 

'    "■^ 

,' 

' 

*- 

;-: 

1 

• 

V 

-  - 

i^^ 

Jk^ 

^11 

fe^^-    . 

*      "^'t 

1 

• 

'.^, 

,r  -^ 

:^^J^t^  eo^el^  Anticipate  a  J„tf.,a  i«pa. 

«Ie«l.  a„.|  reduced  to  the  a,.a.dotf.  eo«p«a«d  •f  ^II!^!: 
v.^'^^'^y-    Themilftialat^igktlT;^ 

<l««Wled  Tor  the  offlee!«^,Malor  Oen«^    T;-        .T 
from  that  rank  and  .**«„«  .^^'  ^  '••nnot  de«wnd 

l^d^^l^    *     '***""»''-'"»«  the  coiiftii„d  ef,  brigade, 
™  *»«W'  and^  aniwei.  i.  a  Brigadier  Oeiieral     If  TV 
,    :^«»»«%«'«lWea^i..»eor-eglerfJ^r^Ll 
:  ^««  >.a.  the^,„h|ect  to  ^^X^^^^^ 

i^d  t<r  M  >J,port«rfity  of  drffendiLjS^J^ 
^•^  Aj  jditiflcatioa  would  hare  «lenced  ZnTa^^      ^^'■* 

^natio.,fe,.'^^.e„t.d  «^  e,:::^^"^  ^ii^:^ 

wWeh  e»,^i„M  irid.  „aievde,,t  ambitloa  hare  ZiTl 
««;e^,ideratioB,^f  per.oaal  ho^oi^d  pSliiSt,^^ 

5  ^«Sl»«(«'f»1»iiMiliiib  liiHttiuy  dtttiei  e»iaioad  ^    '    ^? 

**«f«tf'»»'*f  <5»1A;  Jlirf*dlt«^  ftH»|»confldeBee  a»I^Zj 
ttWteafcahMth* *««»»*-#«  wconB«eBeeaii*fiMl«gpBeg  ^ 


Wp 


--*JJ 


■ilfta|«M«||f 

'•  .; 

wftiiiBg  ife  tfVdeir  a  Cowt.M«rttfi|  to  irf  Ca|^t)^owdit«k  fbr 
fceing  doped  by  the  impostum  of  Jooathaii  P.  Saimiien  and 
olhert.'    What  moekery  is  thiiP^Qat  I  wiU  Bot  trouble  thd 
CoBrt-Martlil  with  eooiBMat^^  tliU«Mt  of  eharg««;»  at 
€apt.  Bowditoh  ii  Bot  bow>  «b  trial,  it  it  iaiBiaterial  what 
were  the  oauiei  of  eomplaiat  agaiott  hiBi^     ^be  law  h»d  ia- 
-, '  tratted  Bie^tbJBdieial  aothority  to  decide  oaHbe  aoffieieaey 
of  the  ehiiplk.    ft  that  authority  haO  be^n  exer^itid  without 
ftlijf  pinifterliBtCBt^  or  ooitupt  aiotivo,  fliiify,  inpaftially, 
aii4  eoDioiOBt(oBaly,I  ani  without  Ikalt.  If  my  optaioB  AobM 
ft8i%  be«B  erroBCoBo,  it  hat  been  hooet^  'ai^  I  mi  ao^faoro 
TetpoBtible  for  thit  exercise  of  my  diM»TetioB,  tlua  thit  eoBrt 
%i«  be  Ibr  theif  judgment  iathocpretcBt  oaie.  ;9ini,k  tho 
»ato^  and  d*OtiBy  of  Biaa,  Bot  hit  erime. 

fhe  leeoBd  apeeiiieattoB  it  Uke  the  fint,  TaiviBg  oaly  ia, 
:^|!airHM''e]i^ressioa  of  the.  tame- ehali^t.  t  :;:,'<    i,-, ;;  %^  ■         ' 
^^^  ^^"^  »p««ifleatioB  aceutes  mo  of  iseoBtitteBey  aad 
diiplMyvlft^,^qB«^li4Hi  ^  whieh  many  doublod.  Mid 
BiMijr  diiferid  Ijiiyifer  eortalB  pertont,  «who  were  paid 
^  *fc*a*o  heea^iteharged  fisomUbe  Salem  Cad«t  oompaBy/^le- 
gaily,"  eontiniied  to  be  miinber.  of  that  eorpt,  or  bebagiid  to 
the  teTeral  standiBg  oompai«*t'  within  whote  territorial  lim- 
^  S^  owreralljr  repined.   I  recommeaded  a  prateeutiol  that 
^itte  Blight  h^iillmitted  t*  the  iBiMtigation  of  a  ooLaeto 
tnbiiBal,  aad  b^^A5teHidlwd*^logal  aathor^.  *.^iL*  r 

iie«li^  ti^tiboriiaate  offietrt.  .  Af  Mgal^ 


^^tojrftom  the  lirtt  ia  eommaBd  to  ^^vate  toldier 
arraaged  aai  appointed  to  e«ery  i»^if»iy  tyttem^ 
f^i«jtli»>«f  the  tfhief  ia  aathoriti  itilllb.  inforauag^ 
iamolt,  and  direett  the  motion  «f  every  «( 
•  If^ame.    Tlieirla^^  it-the  en 
liogmiad.    mtirageBOyit 

^^t^^ffiFi-  >  .r^  .;***«•  *»«»ltioB.iaH(||iartbrma»oe. 

.«.^»ttitt«a ;f»^l4tfct.-;  tli*po|pqi»-o|^|^ 

i'hBiiiei|<llMk»eh8    _ 
tofmilitaiywa^eKB 


rhe,^ 


LL^IS 


m 


■^^ 


« 


'^'      -'l^i^t'? '''t^-i  c-i.i'^ 


\ 


-:vm-^W^ 


.<  -i 


;4. 


•  ■  *  « 


•hould  b«  performed  by  thrSi  '"^''  "''"'  •'"^ 

ed  with  the  eaoaelty  S!!  '"  ''*'^''»''*  "*»  '•««''^ow. 

With  the  klZ,7JZlT''^r  ""  '^^  '^-'I»«'»-«*. 

pfttdi<»g  of  rt«a*e<i4feJTfcL  1.^  **"'*y  •'  thtf 

-i«e  .th.  M^rri  r^trtnrx 

my  aimwer.  41thAn.i.  .i.--  «"'f wwa,  ami  deiAaod 

1    r,l     """»»"««  weir  ttneertaio  nfttore'*«*il*f«*  j-«T^ 

"7  conduct  in  th!«  n«.4:.»i..    i«^  -t    A^    .  .T  *""  r^«?Pi*l 


«.w  —  J  \l  .    '     ■    -  — «=  ■«*i»'»peciii«ation,  and  ei 
"7  conduct  in  thi,  particuUr.  ^i5^#  i^  ^r^^^  t 

The**.*: _^«_  ■^j*^'^  '^c  '■■■^:;->>>  :i3 


The  tyimo.y«f  „.,y  Wtl»fc^i^itM4l£ 
The  I.„er  .,j».„  ..iu^y,    ^  „.«!„. ^.i^Sf** 


;'-t 


^ 


.?. 


<^'  >'^l 


ir./: 


:w .' 


63  '  M 

««»,  even  in  rehti.n  to  maiSal  «ljeeU,  .rfttiy  «fher  ».«, 

ireeljr  to  eipew  hi,  opiBi6M4ft  iMh  CMe  m  ikt  Me  ilM«rUi. 

*we,  (0  .B^uenee, V  to  eontrofttfe  eleetw.  in  thi»  dioioe  >tf 
flpgndier  GtpenW  I^d  he  eapjoy  entri^ie.  or  th.«rt.,  did 
^entice  bjjwea.i«»,  or  indue*  by  reward-^or  intimidnto  b, 
dfin«i...«idl,^pI«etor,  and  f  r,«il  with  W.  to  wte  for  i 

*rS^i^'^  ******  ^^'"'"*  •"**  ""»«»»iif  by.^ddttpt  of 

%,  I^Nre,  but  pot  to  trial  by  «Conit-Ma«tial.,  WMb 
«^.*en.  ,n  eivil  capacity,  »  wj|o  hii  .fi^ 
fti^nfc  and  «plleit  i„  the  .xpro..i*p  JS^jTrflLV*^ 
jr^paMer,  an^  he  wa.  bonnd  in  honor  to  remove  aw  biM 

bf  a  belief  ,r  Mppowti,n  of  a  opnibination  or  «o>.  JnM>f  lo 
^Tent  the  eleetl*^  or  M«oneo  ih^Vote  of  O^t  2^ 
J-ptteh,  with  whieh  the  offiei^l  relm  of  the  p«S«5 
MHn^ele^o^^ 

^^dei- ,n  Chiefi  ^a.  thyM«etn«l  and  p^  4i»eha«ro 
<h  dnty,  and  ip  ,„,^i,e  rejf«h.a.ihle.  4         *  T 

S^^uT^  «y^n^„,„t,^r  it>  Wriy  befo«  ih««,^ 
g^e^to  their  e«n„deration,^  ^To  their  candor  and  Jnouil 
^J^e.«,«eo«thiieau«e.   U  no^^rd  for  n.y  fcibw^&p 

Hl.the.ihilkia,  inguenoe  *!.«  J..J»— *  -*  ^i- *7™™ 

■Md  «li  |npartian 

^•faty  „.  eo^^o,  *''«JiRn«#«^  ^IhTtriM^ii^S 


% 


.^' 


U 


tk* 

^iM£'2'■^i&lT^l*£i^l^'   i' 

%^ 

affifeSsi^SSiK?  >  "^  ,  .».>S4 

ir.^. 

>'  ¥i 


*  >f 


•t :  -r  ' 


f 


1 

•ingh  ft  I 


4 


4 

*"^^*^:j^'*^  »\  W*%d  to  ««««  i,to  all  coin: 
igai-t  officers  under  hi*  eoanband,  or  i»  at  liberty  to 
»  or  not,  aeeording  tn  hi*  own  preMure.  *^ 

TrfainaniirWill  not  eonUnd  tWii  eoHpanderof » 

Aj*retfon,  lil^fte  „  bound  at  th  p.ril  to  use  a  .ou«*^cre: 
w  ;,  r^^"'  ^'f^^"  '^^  »#oWlged  to  iet^n  complaintli 
^!2:^!'*  ''"  ^  **  """^y  *"  nej^ict  that  aeainrt^apt. 

w^eftow,  «ii4  the  ehargebart  of  amjrWa^ted  aature. 
Thg^uje  Capt.  BowditeE  of  partiaUt,^  .  violaiiofl  of 
ItSfrf    ^-'^''^''f'''^  retumsof  hi,  eompany.„f  op. 

tod  thw  dep^ving  flpof  imptfrtant  priMeie.  to  whii 

■*lW!re  entltiyp'V  ■    '^*W>'^-'^-"'  •'=?--,'■• 

^^|5Kthe««gi(|^-^e,  there  m^Ami^  » 

ifttothe  truth  of  ihe  ihargesJ-Jtbat  would  4»e  beeaihe  v^rr 
boimeii  of^ftfe  ed#t.h*  ihbuM  hare  Called.  :Theeharse.  o, 
tk*  ftee.->l»y|ii'fi||(grf.4.«,.t  i»iportMl  jiittt#  «|  tlJ- 


hem 


7* 


^fe; 


'■f^i-'  .«>'/% . 


■  ^. 


T'' 


:..^ 


.»>-« 


im 


t 


• 


:*■ 


^•f  the  •riginaj 


WW  (he.'eoili. 
reipto  dll  com- 
»  iU  liberty  to 
re. 

[>inniancler  of  a 
ipon  the  faeo 

t  laWtJuaJiS 
Bouttd  iisere: 

>n  ,eomp|ain|iii 
a^^Bit  Capi 
iral  rek^eta* 
.rated  luaoK. 
ft  violaiioq  of 
np&ajr,  of  ojp* 

vneotn^aiii^, 
to  wbieh  tKey 

a^.^efb|, 

leeirtiSt?^  , 


05 


•  ^•r"™  PMnishment  for  tth*  m!.-    j      '    jS^EISW'®" 
MJ  «t«.ti.,  I,  u,„j    ™      " '■  "»  '!""'  •'"ge,  U,^  ■ 

"*.,"- "» -PwfcSr«u:,  :.*:  t"?  r- 

to  have' acted  on  thU  comDlainL»i.- 1  "  '"'  '•"^X 

fore  him.  «••»P«*'«^  which  wa.  theo  reguluHjr  be. 

But  the  exenge  relied  OB  by  Gen  o„«j  i     •    .^ 
0»|t.  Bowditch'.  health      c!^.  n    ?         *' '"  **•"  •^**''  «' 

^eealledoBhim^Delrh     r'"*'  "^^''  *'"^*  ««-• 
AobW  dial  a  Court  of  Ino^r       k'.  *"*'  """^  *"'"™"^'*  '"*-'  *• 

veuie-eeof  the  ^^^  «  toTt^Lro^T IL^  ^"^  ^'*- 
te-t.ithejM.ith  hi.  4  or  L^di^r  tro''"" 
P««,  called  on  Capt  Boirditeh  jf-     •    ^ '     *""^'  **  •?" 
^P».i>o»rarteh  and  inquired  of  hiffl,  whether 


'■*|. 


'^5; 


# 


f     '*■ 


^' 


*!^'n  ■^n  \^% 


fi   ^' 


<" 


i)"^ 


6« 


■  *  "Ik  # 

C  ^  *"  afcfojjjititoid  a  C|g|«f  Inquiry,  If  the  ae«,ftit&t 
guikj  qf  4i«^|ige«  alJegeFi^aiMt  hin,  would  he  not  blS^ 
•lio^  to  thinic  himtelf  unable  to  sjibmit  to  a  trial? "  ^. 

I|,appean  that  Capt.  Bf^it^h  rnAed  i^dela/oa  mwmSi 
of  hia  healtli,  andlE  June  requested  a  diseharge.  Wao  thio 
conduct  of  the  lespoadent  according  to  mUitary  usage?  Tfc» 
complainants  apprehend  that  the  regular  course  would  Uva 
iNsen  to  hate  arrested  Papt.  Bowditch  and  i^f^f^d  kia  of  hip 
command,,  and.  for  the  eour^  to  have  ascertained  %ether  Wc 
health  would  have  supported  the  labor  of  a  triai%  tlwjser- 
tifieates  of  physicians  or  surgeons,  and  to  have  adjounjjllon 
Ume  to  time,  if  necessary,  until  he  was  dSk  "^ 

Gen.  Goodale  has  proved,  that  he. did  call  a  Court  of  In- 
quiry, and  therdTore  he  says  he  has  done  his  duty.  The  or- 
der for  this  Court  of  Inquiry  appears  t6  be  dated  thirtecftdayn 
after  the  complaint  agapst  himselfl  It  will  be  for  the  court 
to  determine  what  influence  this  circumstance  might  hai^had 
in  inducing  the  GeAeral  to  act  on  the  complaint  against  Capt. 
>owditch.  The  complainants  also  remark-~that  the  officer* 
J  .  ***"  composed  that  Court  of  Inquiry  were  not  d^taUed  from 

II  *^®  '""*"'  "eoniing  to  law  and  military  usage,  but  were  aU 

1^1        ^  appointed  by  Gen.  Goodale.  uind  they  had  no  authority  to 

give  any  opinion  m  the  eridenS,  w^h  seems  to  be  a  prinel-  - 
pal  object  in  such  cases.    A  Mi#>  ^^»o  appointed  Presi- 
dent  of  the  court. 

in  courts  martial  the  law  requires  that  the  President  «f  a 
^vision  court-martial  "shaU^n  no  c^e  be  under  the  ra^i;  of 
l4t.Col.  Commandant,"^ and  it  is  presumed  he  oughf  to  hold 
the  same  rank  on  Courfitf  Inquiry,  for  the  same  reas« W 
lit;  and  though  the  la^t^oes  not  expressly'  require  it$  eonrto 
■iptial  and  courts  of  im,airy  are,  thcDB  considered  togeth*, 
and  seem  ^  be  placed  on  the  same  footing.  The  qoesSn 
then  arises,  whether  this  court  was  oidered  adl  holden  aeewdl 
ingly  to  l^-and  if  it  was  not,  whether  Gen.  Goodalfrlip|#fe 
ellfeet  yet  iHed  on  the  complaint  against  Capt  Bow^teh. 

As  to  the  8d  cljarge,  the  complaina^  would  iriet,  oh- 
••rve,  that  they  trlit  it  i.  fuUy  supported  by  the  testJEsy  of 


^ 


4 


t 


lid  he  not  bill* 

eky  oa  aceounl 
rge.  WMthi* 
yuMge?  Tfc» 
le  would  kavo 
l|K0d  kim  of  hv 
l4|j|etkep  Us 


iidjoui 


a  Court  of  In. 
luty.  The  or- 
1  thirteettiayo 
e  for  the  eoort 
light  baiai>faad 
against  Capt. 
lait  the  offieerv 
d(taUed  from 
,  but  were  all 
B  anthority  to 
»  be  a  prinei«  ' 
•einted  Preti- 

resident  tf  a 
r  the  rafik,  of 
tngbftol^old 
B  reawmitMl. 
re  i^  eoorts 
■ed  togethi^y 
^he  qa«st&B 
Idea  aeowrd- 
odate^lK 
awdit^^  '^' 

teatufeayof 


jbb,  Mr.  Wor«e«er,  and  others,  and  shoalU'the  esnrt 

^   le  same  opiail*,  it  is  prej|l|d  they  Mi|i|Ll^  to  pro. 

nifllee  it  "degrading,  ungentlenSSUice,  anduKwlMce  eon. 

^h  charge.  It  appears  b^  «^#i4^e  o<  CaptainU*ea, 
body,  King,  and  Webster,  that  6<m.  vlUe  tol#  than  to«|^ 
ply  to  Maj.  White,  wh^neVer  they  wSted.^  discharge  vf 
privates  from  their  respective  independent  companies.  Ur, 
Webb  and  Mr.  Bi^ggs  also  testify  that  ©en.  Ooodale  aeknowl. 
edged  he  had  given  authority  to  Mttj.  White  to  gradt  these 

^'!ftP''    '*  "  *™*  **'  ^*"'*  ^'•»**  *e«*»fie»  tha^  ^te  only 
gemi  order  Ge^foodale  ever  gave  him,  to  his  reeoUeetten, 
W^  when  he  [OoAWle]  was  going  a  journey  of  several  weelta 
in  February,  18^1}  and  that,  he  says,  directed  him  to  transact 
tbe  general  business  of  the  brigade.    Now  here  is  evidence  of 
a  general  order,  as  extensive  as  that  mentioned  in  this  chaige) 
•"^»«8k  Maj.  White  never  acted  under  it,  that  does  not  ex* 
euilfQen.  Goodale  in  granting  it    But  there  is  conclnsi^ye  tes- 
timony  on  this  apint  given  by  L.  Saltonstall  and  Ebepezer  Wor. 
eester,  who  say  they  heard  Gen.  Gbodale  testify  pid^r  oatb 
before  Joseph  B.  Sprague,  Esq.  that  he  could  not  teU  whether 
particular  persons  had  b^n  discharged  from'the  Sidem.Cadet 
company,  because  Maji  Wfajte  attended  to'tAa*  butuuss,  and 
that  lie  had  referred  Oapt,  Swditeh,  and  also  privates  to 
Wni  upon  that  subjeet.  \It  also  appears  i»  evidence  under  the 
third  charge,  that  Gen>Goodale  toM  Ebfiaezer  Worcester 
and  others  that  he  h«d  nover  authorized  their  disehaige  from 
the  Cadet  company.     And  it  dees  not  appear  that  he  ever 
eoffplained  of  M^.  White  for  dis^hai^g  them  withont  an- 
Jh»rity.     Gen.  Oopdide  says  it  was  for  the  eonvenifuce  of 
liese  mcwt  who  wanted  their  dischaives,  and  that  the  iaten. 
*»»  W||,  ^  tliey  shoQid  apply  tbrttugh  the  Briga4e  Mi^or 
toWm,  he  living  in  Danvers.    But  he  referred  Capt.  Webster 
#||«Av«li  to^.  White,  and  also  Capt.  Peabody,  who  ». 
P^  to  ^  penonaHy  fbr  the  difcharge  of  two  privates.    / 
T^e  manner  in  whiek  these  dieeharges  ate  ewtci^ln  ¥nj, 
*yM^tf»9f^  i$  po  proof  th«t  t^ejr  ^ere  made  by  order  tf 


'\.    h 


"m 


r 


^1 


r 


■4' 


'  »■»  ■ 


■t»y 


68 


tryofth*  ^aipk^ge^of  ,^1  privatei' from  C.p?EL 
rs""!©  be  by  the  OAnAm^'g*' |M>der^!S 


<  Tl"  cmplainw,,  «,.,ider  Ih.  power  to  di.el.™  privatlj 

♦k—      Tu  ^  "  **"""*  ••«  taeccssary  to  describe 

niSllL  ^     ''""P*"^-    By  ^i«  practice,  individ, 

^  mayj.e  oppre„ed,  and,eompa„ie«  disorganized  b;  offij-r., 
who  »»  not  responsible  for  go  doing.  ^   ' 

anHni^NT^'''"*"*'  ""'"'*  ^••''«»'  *«  notice  the  irremlar 
m!L  A     1 '. ''"'""'"'«  *"  *"•'  "*»  explanation.      The  laJ 

'"..p;«r  be  d...^,;,  .i  „.*.,  Vk' add^.3'- 
«» «.r.i..  f «'.;;""  ?^' "  '■"•  ■""«*r  ••,  jifc, 

Mgiiter  and  execute  hia  orders. 

#»»l»ehwT5e.    The  fcc(.  stated  in  thi.  di^il^iSt 
proved  |^R«h,rtIl.n.oa.,lH.     Wa.  it  nTSLi^T^ 

CI  .f  ot  S7 "  ^-^ ''  '*"  ^"^  ^-^ 


* 


f 


.^apiw- 


$ 


11^  * 


fs,  th« 
Qaptr 

by  him,  wiR. 

•c  proved,  the 
nmilitary  eon* 

large  private? 
•er,  vested  by 
cftnno||||Mf. 
cretionWrh* 
he  praeticf^of 
f  to  describe 
in  the  situa- 
tice,  individ* 
d  by  o%grs, 


he  irregular 
exercised  by 
The  law 
the  Captain 
srson  of  the 
to  which  he 
lopportuni. 
rery  impor- 
tifieers  of  a 
ier  Qeowal 
ted  by  tike 
ible  to  t|»^ 

^9ffieer4 


lira  el 
litary  eoa4 


He' 


tli^sUtia.. 

\t  no  dis- 

1^' General 

v^tl^s  peqttest 


ea  th«  <^ei4bV  peijonally,  ai^ 

|f  the  j||-igade,  ¥nd  the  <^iipP||gir  otA 

•jji^ges  sHiaald  pass  in  this  brigade  until  aJEl 

WW  elected,  and  then  Gei^kloodale  ke^t  C©ii 

nearly  two  months  in  his  pockefc'^  Did«jkeOTive»atiou'wiA 

the  Cotnmander  in  Chief  e||eose  Oen.  Good«|e  f<w  wfthhotll. 

ing  Col,  Lovett's  request  so  long  a  tiilie?    The  eopiplainante 

^rehend  that  he  was  not  bonod  to  notice  aify  order  not  in 

writing,  that  no  sneh  order  can  be  t^^  least  exeape  fi||^i«^ttt 

doing^is  duty,  which  obliged  him  to  forward  Cd^Jevitt^s 

i-^jjijMion  to  the  Adjutant  General's  office.     Had  he  done 

this^  would  ^Nik^^  done  Am  dvlty,  and  the  resp«nsihility 

wQild  have  rest^ntircly  with  the  %a^ander  in  «hlef.  i 

There  must  have  been  some  partieular  «nd  powerful  reasons 

to  have  impelled  the  General  to  the  bonneil  Chamber,  for  it 

surely  eannot  be  usual  for  eommanders  ofdi^Hons,  when  re- 

sigijp^ions  are  offered  to  them,  to  wait  on  the  GovdMbr,  and  ^ 

quire  whether  he  will  grant  discharges.      Sneh  a  ^fetom 

would  open  a  door  for  incalculable  mischief,  ihonl^  there  un. 

fortunately  be  a  Commander  in  Chief,  who  would  Connive  at 

and  assist  a  Major  Oieneral  in  procuring  appointnetdk  for 

fovorite  officers.  '^^ 

«th  charge.    All  the  ehi4|||  made  agf^fist  Gen.  Geeylale, 
to  which  the  attentiaiof'lthis  court  has  b^  eaUed,  at«  im- 
portant,  but  thisis.oiTtlie  highest  nature  that  can  be  exhibited 
against  a  dIMb  %  an  impoMant  military  eomnttod.    It  has 
been  objeeted  that  this  charge  is  not  <«  fully  and  plainly^v 
subrtavtially  atid  foi-paily  diesecibed,'*  as  ii^  required  in  thf 
(|l(:eliil^i«Nl«  iSth  article  of  the  pill  of  Rights  of  lias. 
sachtttfi^t'TliiB,  it^l  be  observed,  Je  part  of  th«  same  ». 
tiele,  hk#1ileh  i^  is  protAed,  that  ^f ery  snbj^t  iiall  W^  1 
rij^tii  he  ftlly  heard  by  hfiM^f  V'1iMii«pnse(  at  his  de«. 
tNg"  tod  yet  i^as  been  decided  la  all  cfoarts'marHal  sinee 
the  formation  of  the  Bill  of  Rights,  and  correctly  decided,  th^t 
a  defondajittemMt  be  beard  by  M»eennsel  before  tbe^TtThe 
whole  o#tUs  article,  it  if  humbly  jiresHmed,  refon'piMipa-  • 
(jr.ir a«t^r«^>  %  Ma^  'm  «ir>uts>f  kif,''nr ««t  >; 


»t. 


!•» 


4ty 


'■'■M 


,/i 


t 


% 


i:*.% 


?0 


isift  trie  that  the 


IT 
ulMtai 


Uy  aud  siiRtantially  del... 
«o  AB  the  nature  ffythe.  4 


eoarts  mAf^ar  or  mtritimc. 

fiot  i«  ftiyj  I^Jrlaigljr,      * 

i«  the  ch«.g^lt^i,  as  druch  »„  *,  tne  nature TTf. the, ^K. 

•daUt^of,  a.»i8.,„ual  in  military  Wplaintg,  and  ag  jmII, 

r^Hire..     ToTi«yfl||en  more  particular  would  have  burthen- 

ed  the  complaint  wiTTAIl  the  partteular  acts  and  ebaverial,,,* 

produced  la  evidence  in  support  of  this  charge.  , 

Thexespoudent  is  accused  ^t  "interfering  in  the  election 
of  a  Brigadier  Goneral,"  and  of  "using  undue  and  imprijb 
influenaj*.ith  a  dwign  to  bks  the  mind,  of  the  voter.,"  wd 
thus  to  effect  the  election,     this  is  the  substance  of  '^' 
«nee,  and  as  a  consequence,  it  is  statedjg|.the  seaii 
ha*  heeo  superseded,  according  to  the  i  Jtof  Gen.  Goooaio. 
and  general  dissaUsfaction  and  discontent  produced.     Un&r 
th«  charge  the  respondent  cannot  be  taken  bj  surprize-he  is 
suffici«IWy  notiaed  on  what  ground  he  is  to  meet  the  com, 
I^iiants,aiid  it  was  to  be^resumed  that  an  offioer  in  thaiiKh 
rank  «f  the  respondent,  would  have  been  fearless  of  anMvi, 
dence  that  eottld  have  been  brought  to  support  sueh  a  charire. 
;    ^.t^^  •"PPorted  %  the  tesUmony  that  ha.  been  pL 

ir  m       '*'P"'"  ^""^•^  •^*'''*»«<'  »^  Captains  Pettee. 
|J.n^«^tearns,  Richardson,  Lt.  Tapley,  Lt.  Porter,  Ensign 
treston,and  othe^^that  on  t|g|aturday  and  Sunday  previo« 
to  the  elecUon^of^rigadier  GlTral,  (.»  May  last.  Gen.  Good- 
ale  called  on  them  i„  Danvers,  MiddletoJ  a^d  Salem,  and  re- 
quested  them  to  sign  a  paper  h.^prodoced  to  thap,  promising 
-7-*^Maj.  Flint  as  Oolong  of  the  «th  B^:e'nt,  ,tZ 
would  a^humm  min4  in  the  choice  of  a  Brigadier  llen«al 
or  .n  other  words,  if  be  would  vote  for  Col^EgtounMS^ 
adier  GeneraU    Gapt  jp-Jirft  further  tej^ife^'SSS^ 
Whioh  aatlttesliim  to  the  fulL.t  cre^USM  0^^!^"!! 
ed  him  to  si,,  an  ^^g^i^  pfedp^g  J.i.  u,ard  and-3L£* 
to  votefor  Maj.  Flint  a.  C.lond-if  he  won^d  vota  t^ 
Putnam  a*  Brigadier  General,  teliinghi.,  4  U  woll  E 
it,aIM|^e  -^^^^^^^^l^JJ^t^^  , 
and  they  would  '^ft  it  there,"  Uurt  "they  Ma«Su^ 


"tt: 


*t. 

• 

V, 

5-  ■■'.: 

,» 

# 

• 

bg 

fe..: 

,..,(.  ..-.^ijfe 

';:.A:, 

v,.A 

,#■■ 


i^,w  •-'^ 


'  % 


71 


*    li 


.^.  difat  «<UMii^tliS^ld  kn^aj.  Fliof •  Tofe  Ibr'OoL 
iipf  if  ito  eould  aot  see  sdti4l[PQg  from  niiw  the  «^d» 
oi|  majoXt^  of  thjB  offieert  of  the  regiino^  t«i|rflew  that  he 
■Iwu^  not  'ie  Boperseffiftd  n  he  Toted  for  Od.,Patnani)"  and 
when  the- witness  reiufed  to  sign  the  pafjlj^  sayings  he  •hwM 
he, ashamed  of  it,  the  Oeneiml  said,  «it  may  be  kept  a  seere|<^ 
In  several  eonrersationf  Oen.  Goodate  told  Capt.  Flint 
^t  «Col.  Putnam  Oiould  be  ehosen;"  that  <4f  some  officers 
•arte  Hsrward  to  vote,  he  should  arrest  th^  for  facpef  hh*' 
•ond^**.  that  «if  he  eould  f|et  a  tie,  Dr.  KittPed|^j||Pho  had 
gf^flipiuenee  w:ith  the  Gavemor,  was  to  write  to  kim^r^d 
Puiham  would  bSBmissioned;'*  that  "the  officers  must  have 
a  neeting,  and  a^rea  'to  support  Maj.  Flint,  or  w»  shall'lose 
his  vote.''  Hq  went  after  the  witness  to  go  to  his  honsf'^hen 
Haj.  Fiint  was  there,-  and  when  the  witness  hesitated. on  the 
w«iy,  said,  <*if  he  sees  yon  hang  haek,  it  is  all  over,  and  Put* 
tlaqiiriU  leseliis  election.?'  Re  said  also,  that  '^f  CoC  }1||- 
ey's  fi-iends  were  not  at  the  pool  at  the.  time  'anointed,  ke 
s|iouId  close  it  precisely  in  Ibnr  minotes,  and  they  might  help 
themselves  if  they  could;"  and  at  the  same  time  he  told  Capt. 
Flint,  that  <<WiR>re  Col.  Hbvey's  friends  he  expretfied  himself 
Ikvorably  to  his  election,  but  was  determined  Pntnam''skovld  « 
he  elected."  And  tltffi}is^4HlryTeatai|i|»  believe  kim  sin* 
cere  in  his  determittAtib%  not  only  from  kit  -eonduct,  as  we 
kave  stated  it,  previeus  to  tke  election,  but  at  this  time  and 
afterwards^''  The  Ibir  ^atletings  were  concluded  in  fifteen 
minutes,  the  report  Wte  made  on  the  spot,  f^he  and  Col. 
Vj^j^tnam,  a  brMherof  the  candidate  f(i>^^Bgadier  Gen- 
fip^,  iirai|,  to  the>  CouncU'Chamber  with  it  frorn'Oanvers 
plains,  more  than  fifteen  miles,  in  less  than  an  hour  aiid  a  half, 
as  he  told  Col.  Jethro  Putnam  and  David  T^lkiQs,  ^Iplg, 
that  «  he  had  exerted  himself  as  much  to  nyf^m.  pDtnatn's 
eommission,  as  he  could  have  done  if  it  were  to  gain  his  own 
salvation!!!'*    1        '      \  ' 

Does  not  all  Ais  amoQlit  to'a^improper  and  iinodlwrlika 
Jnterferenee  in  the  election,  and  the  use  of  an  undue  inflcenee 
(b  birifike  aili^i  elf  the  electors?  For  what  did  Oen.GoodaIa 

•  \ 


*L 

*■■■  ■tr 


■  * 


:4' 


/>«>  . 


£ 
72 


"^ 


^.^ 


rfcpe«jdly  vi.it  the  Co^w?*'  ^n  <^ejf?  Whj  rid 
tfceiiHi  regi««ntep  the  p|||ay  and  the  Sabb, 
v.,u.tothe'^%?    >%^id  he  relJi.  Coip^et 

eMiioii  ttfwtf    IiWLead  oltviaitmi..  tl.1^  - 

ti^,  gl,oul4  he  not  have  8(u<B^  the  li^iik  initu,:^       ^ 
%  f'-J^w,ed«eorHi,4^,|#Ha.eS^ 

aboMt  ftnuhe  b«*dAiil.,e^rins  o^te  for  a  fovork^  ««««, 

«ly|fepf  from  the  <jon\  ^ 

j07«4l'8  request  to  the  pw»[ 

1SPP«»{»at'^it  to  Fvobennan- 

CoK  Lo,»ett¥  itate  of*nlfi*to 

Ji-event  hia  voting  if  he  atteiii^  th* 

-sr  wuse,  that  the  Gpyemw  t^llAjn,, 

eU^^:   t     li^      ""  *^**^*^  ^  tf^Ms^e,  that  iiidfe, 
#J|^.  «lH.a^pa,MiU  after  tli«  e»eetio.i^f  a  Brigadi^K: 

3*ilCh^t*  t^'^^*^^  of  the  eleeC  tX 

VohD^^phamber  himwlf,  should  he  not  have  deUberatlv 

^he  erfbpla,nant.  woulrf  sngge«t  to  the  notice  of  ihe  eolrt 
^  the  Governor^  offiee  ^p^  ^^^Mun  aftJ^I^ 
,  ^  ha.tyv„.e^  G      o.odaIe,a„d  thati^tiie  ^eantimeUlp 
nam  WM appointed  and  eon.n.i„ioned.    Itisaho^fL  wl 
-peetable^ni^-offieer ha.  been ..perBeded/acI^dt^^  o  the 
'     .ntent  exp,e..ed  b.  Gen.  doodal.  iL^Jol^J^^^^ 
Gene^  Goodale  eontend.  that  hi.  dy  motive  iXX 
%n.^  the  ^itt.n  p.omi.e.  of  the  offieer.  to  "^te  Z^^ 

'    CrLTardl'*"'  t"  *"  ^'^--^^^-^  th.infl„Lvf  3 
lnger.oll  a^d  «fl.er.,  who  had  told  him  there  wa.  a  JLi.-      . 

te".1'  °"':  ""i  '"'J-  •""'  "•«  »»■"«'-  .Ito. 
•f  .f  h.  ,,W  for  C,g^..„,.,j^„„y  ^.^ 


,1 


■m 


"iir>! 


.  ttdtiiiile't'iiuiii 


jif»  to  Odl.  q!l^:  '4b4  -/i, 
pheey  #»  «<^«t,  and       * 
ire  irj^lMiiBo  «tM«im» 


Capi  lagenoj 
liBt,  WM  snpenediidtl- 
«|ff  Midil^SailbBM  iMTiqg^lieMi  VMd  ofl  l|it|.  FllSlip 

Did  til#|l«ftiiAuit?t  eondaat  admit  aflUfez^UMtioii 
him^  w<fild  he  bM  liRl^  jM^led  on  iteaj.1nii 
tent  dwtinij^in  d|fBBee,  to  KH^WIwther  ke^^A 
to BiflueB^e  hlni''ln  hit  Tote? ■'  v.* 

'4b  if  it  were  ttae  that  otken  hail  iStenipted 
WKaiy  ef  wlridl^im[itmt»|«vtiet^er 
'b»««By  czeMe  tor  tbe,)«fefldBet  of  Gcb^ 
eireHBttti^ll^  juetiff  htm  in  attetepUi^;'  to  gaU 
[i^.  Flint  m^iM.  jPwtoaBi,  uRt^f  i^mdiBg  «i;K  or.  Mi^  » 
otteen  to  vote  tot  Mi^  Ffiat?  i)*r;it^t  }e  ^otioed  thillii|^>« 
Aint'ipffjk  doable  opwatMrn^alTeetiog  the  hvedmn  of  the  elee*  i 
tkwof  a  Bi%«dier^hHi«raI,aBd^#i#Coli»el  who  was  to  ta|»^^ 
;  afte||rard8  elected.  /  ,    ■''fi^' 

Bui  Gep.  Qoodale  was  aot  gnilty  i^  this  edfcdaet  iHSli^m 
cfAQl^tt*,  o»  his  shoaldera,  his  kwottd  1^  his  ttde^^^lkMlj^ 
iMiad  of  his  dlvisiOB}  and  therefwe  lie  tttfthn  if  Mt  lial^  (b 
be  tciw^jpur  it  Nllibce  a  CoBrt-M«rti«ly  heeaBa»-lMii'm)|,ji.ii(>i.|it, 
ii%'iB''ttlioffl^ial'e«^tt7^  ■^^,^^"«■•■•'' ^'^  ^^'  -/.v.^^^'^y':-  inc  ^ 
It  M  thejjiride  of  «iic4Mi4liiM<Wl^l^^t  militia  •«' 
eers^are  hut^  eitizen  soldiefs.  7h*«f»«^^maiaeie)ni  «n  to 
bkBd^,thaj(  jMtioBB  whieh  seem^H  be||i|  theirf  rivato  ci^ae* 
i||Filii^fte^ntI)^||:^^  JylituyidliHmeft.  The 

plJMi^e  4lore  advaBoed  wobU  lead  to  gt«at  ab»ri%j  mid 
mit#iff^;'.  The  highest  offimees  are  eoMmitted  by  offisan  wheii 
llH^i^Jmyia  or  acting  befor^  the  f^lie.  Soppose  ^o  C«lr> 
«l^^  JIhigimmits  were  lavfoUyv  i^filbred  J^^eir  sap^rioi; 
#tti^  mi  a  partieuUr  duty;  and  «|^#i,ii|||d|yM|||^  aot  obIj 
j(ii||W.  to^ebey,  but  eaert^  ||jppB^iil|!ii>P^^ 
••fgMrinMUimi.fof'.the  iMaiiij|«iT]IM«  i^giaflf Jl^^^pp  wd 
li|ilifv^4lill^othor|«g^  while  If  if  hasy  ia  eiftctint  ^ 
'■liiljliidj'^he.is  •oaii^his.pffiplU»^l»p«ity}.'i>Bt  ifl|#t 
lli^  aeittg  ift  #most  impjutoBt  iMun|^  ia  hn'offle^al  ea» 
iMeity,  Mjiil«.lii«  i#4*l  iBtai^es?    And  ihvU  M<Mi 


:^: 


S 


^jS/sSSito 


St',  .f  • 


.'^■^ 


pit, 


'm 


», 


?<- 


:  rywi': 


■'m^r^-.m)^^' 


H 


#ncttei  •6eti<a  cf  a  pd|Hkeft«d4dat«  to  ««  offiwi^thf 
••^'■*^'"W|%P<'«q^  wWwe  i».  Bae^MriFy\omaiitt«4, 
when  ii»t«e^«irM% lA  te  ttifokO^  M|Meity.  #i»  tk»«M* 
■^^^mB^^^Q^e  only  mHswed  «.«.  ijJIaM.  th^ftw 
«te«lMat%e>n«iiied  Bt  iJi*  •keli•^  when  tlMre  w^  n« 
#P«rtt,rt^fcr  Mil  to^l»MW|iiii^  wmotiw  fo 

r4»lwi|^^Si^ted  M  he  mju,  hiildiag  ii>^|ih»a 

iithr  wiipi|f|it,iiiiftyaw-w"  *^pger  wm  iMefMt- 

f  Mliti^.«taiiilet,  hc^4r«»  a«tiii9  a.  •'Ma^^iMDa, 

I  1m  n«Ue  iW  hii  MBifafat,  oahM  ^n'  offieiP  %!  th» 

tert  artifice  mj  be#|iHjS'«f  ll»g«aaTOl«Mj|pa4Mtwlfc 


.fir'f: 


"%■ 


^ 


,,j3Tpi^^**^**»*wikf?ii*e  in  an  eketioa  bjoaoilMr  in 
Jl*^^'****^*  Mtuatio^  i.  a  Wgh  alTeaM.  Tha  ralw  an4 
"■•^  •'^«*^«  af  •ar-fcleatiTe  rights,  d^nd  ebtitaly  aa 
0ifir-rlkwiiiii.-^)nd^r]iwtty^    Aft  iatorfereaae  la  a  viidaitJaB  of 

the^riiMa^Afrntt  tfca^^ola«t.vU^e  artHliait  tend*  Jdettfay 

■  tiit -«aa«aeaa»a|yi,»,  1|ipi|§  i,  iH^^miUM*-  .oldier.  aad  t.^. 

IBUl  V ^_, 

^•taatt  i«4^||»  aatilK  (m^  ia  tbireai^^^ 

^r^^m^^f/iA,  the  TOle  «f  iH^itti^is^l^^^ 
oMt  ta  Mat  tM  ha|«  af  fewfrd  hy  baiien  «r  affiaci  it  a«  mwA 
hHtei^yjUi^ol&raf  gold.     An  atteBi]pt  t#.,pfo«iil«  Toteaip! 
il^flVrii  •  HiT  •«!«•  «f  tleettre  righta,  thalf  H 
,  ^''<IWIiii|M^ta^i«aeatMf'4i^pen^ 
MrtiriMMet,  imfr^^^  haM  in  eiM|M^p«a  hliHeir. 

Tlie  eojBdnat  a#  an  oiBifer  ia  lite  k^^li^  hanofahfe  nA 
arthatcapondent,  "hanldhevwialild  witkj^4|i^l^^ithaii 
iaacaaarily  a  great  iaAuaaee  oa  th^ae.  and^r  U«  immimi. 


aHMdi 


^ 


\ 


\ 


71 

On  the  ttfllMt,  mneh  depc«d«  the  ehu«^ter  of  ih«  txr^iul^ 
him,  fWim  the  eoatmander  of  a  cb^pii^y  to  the  Cteneral  ef  a 
diyision.    11  is  of  ^extreme  importaaee  that  hejI^MVit  ovM 
be  (Mpeot*^  of  dMteiiorable  or  nniUfl^  Mnl^et^'for  it  matt-  . 
leisen  eonfideneofn  him,  wai^  tend  to  inatah^fdiaatiAp  Md  eigk 
Aision.^  But  if  high  t^meea  againat  military  iMg^  art^-S^;. 
law  of  the  Und  ate  toUbi^diB  high  oOeen;  it  wiU  fWMft 
nSflraint  from  those  of  i|irior  f^k,  and  the  militia  willl4 
iwitager  of  general  disorganii^atioii.    ^"MCj^e  there^  k  tej^ 
l|^  dot^  of  eoarts  martJkl  ewefaljy  t»  shield  t^  jJK*lN|3^ 
i«dd|p|lil|m  Ihhe  aeematiotit)  yet||^hciMTer  the  rihii>— yp 
hibiled  have  been  siifported  by  evitkttee,  hewerei'  mpkraMHT 
Ae  tatk,  their  dotf  and  their  honor  oUige4hcA  ^^tlg^Sl^i 
and  to  i|giet  a  panishment  denaiided  (^  the  d|enee,  WK'm  > 
•hall  di^  their  disiqiprobatioB  of  the  erioMi'alid  deter  oU^ln 
from  imitatiaK  the  {Mmieiom  ezaM^.     ^  ft «  ^r  ^  -  r'»  ~$v^^ 

^    .  BAHUEL  BRIMBL£COM[,  Lt.  (Sol.  ftr  hi||A» 

<^  and  is  behalf  of  th»eoipm|UiiMMiia» 

'  «*>^  ^^  <i>'^8MBS  ^  •'ti«0L9»|^  ^lU«tat^ 
Nidbf  BifeiayplniniiHti  in  tha  trial  of  Mf^.  Oca.  Goodal«. 


)4v    :.     '     , 


^^?Sf^ 


iV 


.  *■ 


.■  «1-^  ' 


* 


.i' 


f 
\ 
V 

i 

\ 


M 


1* 

4; 


■»' 


t 


^ 


'.'.TSfe'' 


i,:  :^t:^\:^^sM 


«-^...:-- 


nf  KOfEWKXPLAITA'rOIIY.    rf 


NO 

(•  «A«  order  fw  th$  CV 


Ji: 


i  ..-.'  «^ 


I* 


e    *lS    *'  '*■    •■ 

«  Court  "^^^mp  on  Capt  Bof9itch  wu  hol^'  pursumi'ft  ihi. 

^\J^m»  alWl  the  proceedinm  immcdSately  transtn^d  to 

but  he  h«i  never  made  any  order  iip6if  It.    U,  iqipe^iid 

that  CfiMi  fioi|ri(t«h.  In  the  annual  ntum  of  (isl^Mway, 

■eveial  prnatea  vkh  vnty  «qu^nient  tequired  by  lawt  a(td 

Mme  peropna  t^atified,  that  tbey  had  Qftr^r  fA/tA  or..«qiup|)««l 

Ivea  aa  pirateall  s«id  GOWDBfiyf 

A  t^t/ereiuc  tP  -Em.  MtmtmiH  WebfsttegthMtrft  %%  and  9.    « 

4lh  |u|fF'||lt],  tht  Cac(it«  eomfany  was  oidere^  to  meet  "to  cele- 

th^|f^on<lIndepend(nce,V  meaning^  to  perfofti  eacort  di^ty  for  a 

locntie  woi^easioii.  .iThe  federalistt  of  the  town  alio  celebnoed  the 


..V 


^7,  and  had  «|||||p»idiDn,  at  wMcb  several  ofthe  padet  company  viah- 
^iilifi) frf^^^-^SiT^ i^'i-Tt^r  ilH nut  mrnijrii  rfni^ilj .iijjijlx.^'J..  im. 
ne^atdy  after,  Ci^it.  Bo^ush,  wtead  of 4>o*«ou<^  ttii>  fb^a^he 
fer  abienee,  of  bu  own  authi|(^p||iui|^p^^  f'^.tbe  company, 

and  applied  t<>,  Bd^.  Maj.  WhitjB  to^Jhl^i^  the  otliera  Ifacj^rgedi  which 

«M doM  ''''*' JUUBHOI'  '''^j^'"  '"  '^'¥!**"^ *"* '^y  1*^1  <:•*»«■  C*pt* 
Bowditi^lJkn  inffl^|i>,th«^a|H«ii|r«%bie  atandu||com|^«,  that 
thoie.)iiietidk  weM  Jio  longer  me^ibera  ofibel^ukt  compaiqci  amUliay 
rer«  ^^jHed  iA^ia^mi  withfii  '«»M*'Umtta  the|^^  gerenlly  teiAd- 


■f«^'' 


.% 


4^     ■"-    ■ 


i't.- 


■■■*■ 


MB' 

'^Mfpbyc.on  ^dh  ti^»t  «»«ider«d,fW«<  dited  tkir. 

before  the  ord^  #  Gen.  (illiiU  1^  the  Comtfof  Inqujiy  xm 

Bowdi^^  <|wy|t(t^lljlil  to  jltvc  4<>ichen«d  the  GeMnO, 

■■■".*■■  ♦■;■*'■■•- , 


■•■*^Wf'sSi 


^ 


Y 


Ik::. 


1  ;  '. 


■'W 


/-jfy 


W^' 


n 


'*te 


',4 


iro»nikr  in  CHicf,  it  U  not  published  by  authority; 


*)re  tl»  Comm^mkr  in  Chief,  it  W  not  publwhea  oy  auuiomy;  but 
haabecn  iSUea,  with  the  rcm4rk.  p^ctding  a^  foHowing  it,  for 
the  in«r«  tmmX  ipformaUoB  of  ^e  public  "po"  tl»  *'»o'«  tu^ject 
of  compUint.l 

.  *     *'  *  .  -*  •]••'., 

y  ^»  d«»pitlo^tteiU|(b  of  A«4eadenW  democracy  »o  piace  tket^imf 

it,  ««er  (A«  maj«llity  ex|l««tod  during  the  last  year  as  weU  to  the  «Mf/f«a 
•tatothe'4l||jl'«iMioni»'1!|*^-.,,  *  ■  '       1       ' 

'  "aHB>e/«»  «l««'i«'"  ^^^  th#Tac«icy  of  ^Qga^  was  ordeM  bjj  <^. 
«  2P^.  to  J»e  h«lden  owOd  April;  Goodale  presided,  and^ltfed|^t- 
"-^ '  "sAJed.  This  el^iptioot  agfupst  which  a  protestwas  inimedia»lyilodjf- 
fieofficei^the  Adjutant  Geiicf!!^,  waseyenby  Gov. Gerj|||feclar 


.  ,.  ,,•.-■1.     .,,  -^ 


«^  4rr^gular  ««l^|pii  ,  Still  however  th«»  democrats  did  not  ^m'  •»*" 
carrying  PutnaS^  another  trial.  Top  thc|«»U  knew  that  ^9^*^  <»- 
their  M||<  Gov.  Gerry  and  Gen.  Gocy^ale:— tie  only  difficidty  td^ricounUr 
that  the  majority  nf  xleetort  via*,  ^aiiut  tKem.    This  hot^^t  they 

tec- 


was  tf 


thought  wpuld  not  be  p  insuperab\^  .obsuclci  for  by  orderii||p 
ond  elecUclj^Vore  the  Ntum  of  |^aj.  Fairfield,  one  of  the 

*  known  to  beWMsed  to  i>utnani,  ani*=  befoare^  the  vacancy  of  GdL 
<'        abould  be  fil(PB|nd  esp«cially  by  corrupting  and.  bribing  Ma|. 

proved  to' tl>c^^||^ingpag«s)  no  dc^lbt.was  enterttifawd  by 
that  they  8houIdjH|ed;  and  tliey'diainioceed! 

On  ^  3d^4P^iR:ei^.th«  plan  of  the  campaign  had  been 

^'       den.  Goodale  ord6icitbig|||^onto  bS  heldonthe  35th  Bfjiy.  :;l4iaiedi 

atel/  t;»e  friends  of  QoL  V^m  *PI^J«d  fot  hi*  discharge^  knowili^  there 

was  am|fte  time  to  fiU^lhe  vs^cyi  %m  the  Genend  oba^nately  Refused 

to  permit  Col.  Lovett's  aro^cation  to  be  sent  to.^e  office  of  tfie  Adjutant 

Qd^M.  ^Hgin^A^t  {^  G^netal]  had  c«)nWrse^«ith  povj  Gerry, 

#  and  that  pov.  Geriy  hi4  diiisrted  him  to  permit  no  r«£|[natioi»s,  until 

**    qfier  tke%etiM.    TiA  vi|lAu««esin,the/|MReg.  wre  fil^mm^iately, 

#    as  here  tli*y  expi^^  in  theif  |hift.  ,»|rho  j^Mi  P^^f^** 

'  ^-  l^re  an)iM»>#4|>tain  l^s  cUscharge.  and  actil4fymade«^  the  con-    .«. 

.      dttct  of  Gen.  Qooii^directly  to  C|o«r.  Geny.  «aA  j)odg«l|^<»|»  ip  the ' • 

||< .    Adjutant  G«iJiyra  1tlE^>--the  Govemoe  howiejtor  *ij^frfeifln>Me.  a«d 

f*»# i»«6Me*to  int«ri|»»j^»6  i|||.(lhes^!i|9BrincipM  ""*«S^PF#  '■»  ^^ 

t  )     seteme4iiidoi^t*enty.fifthof  Mayi(the  day  ol«w  A||:«lertion) 

#  the  vote*  w*ns  equlril):  d|»id#i|t^^  Thia  h^bwf  fcreseen  %&  #«<9 
lAosenu^  0e^8uliM:rifaidVtil«WW!>g  PROTEST.  w(io|rth«T 

'      hrt  act^gifcprepared  *«f*r«  tlie3f#lt»ni«a«ifr*lecaQn:--.      - 


"'M 


■m  *# 


k»  -* 


7% 


.■?.* 


JB.    *■■ 


-m.,wr 


fe...    *"*'■'' 


t.%*  I 


*?¥  '  -i- 


V 


% . 


78 


m-^ 


•:#• 


;  I*  ",  ! 


Sf 


.'* 


* 


m»ll.»d  k-.l""'*™^  ""•"^  «"»»»<  U".""^ 

•♦  »  imte  Ihe  cm  rf  .  „fc_:  •     .""«'"»« •""Iwi.iiHl  now 
«»™  fc  d»Ue.  of  hi.  ..Id  ili<..lZ:JI?^  "?  '"""-P"*  •»  ■»- 


In  fact  I 

Inff  Oca 

*¥• 

\      Lofcttl 


yoferkx 
Lorittt, 


^4l 


kftlu»b 


IT- — 


^ 


■•* » 


jr 


I 


r 


W 


•'V*^  #^ 


\f" 


'^jSlk 


■-i^ 


'^^ 


r 


.Hjf' 


tmdtrt 


i^flT 


iB' 


"If, I 


wdSdOiv.  o^ 
Goodale,  fliqf 
««>  coqunand^. 
«  Dawrign'«ii 
■  of  Brigadier',.    . 
[liMinpttravIl     ^ 
ime  «imI  plao»'^» 
lid  CMiicen»1^ 

sn  TOted  tSe. 
Major  GeiM. 
cA«iar  of  Mi4 

JonttluBil.: 
*«d  t>ri|rtde, 
use  and  cz* 
«fl(  iuid  now 
Ulsaidtima       f 
!tei^toper< 
un;  of  laid 
t^nf  ahicid 
>t  he  mi^^t 
written  re- 
l|ilBin  wrf. 
"idDWf*   .( 

ly  •olijjhed - 

wetttothi' 
vettroigjt^ 
Mrioaa  to  "'^ 
sriyrefin, 
Mflirion:^  >-:¥ 
oof  thwe- • -*.  ■' 
IfeonMlrta 


1^ 


^ 


■y.. 


«>>«i^-j|m«ui<;  ^if^Slbpity  ami><i|g|><tM»'l^  Lt  Col.  Loutt  ^ 
in  fact  ai)4  lb  tb#Vii*  •eaning  ^f  the Jaw  civate  a  xiattmtf  in  aaid  )>riff- 
'  •de,!«nd  lifiMAelectioQ  wtui  thbcfoiii  JoMq^in  violation /)f  the  ataitd- 
%iff  Gcnwnir  0>d«ib  <A««  m  <(&«^  thattkt  MIft  m$iMlft*atMeim  anJU- 

'  •■"•:,,  '"'^      _  - "     *■» 

to  procure  ki$  dUcliarge^ 

ekction,  tkM^l^tim»0f 

miitnftfrttut  iitarfr.*'' '■ '  W^Pi^  -4 "".*'"  ^V'^W'tv**'  "* 

cei  aad.fitf  the  remona  afbifeaaid,  to  eiftoti tb»- 

>  -         ;  '^  .■■■■. 

Biigkdier  General,  ia  npt  according  to  tbe^truo 
jif.the Iwr.a ii0^tt,'1^rtfmitdM«i<Xy*ci^^'.   ^,,* 
|ipi»'  IffVnrSi^ai  deeply  impretsod  vith  the  itn{;;»ti|D«!9    '. 
j^fifOMiilf hinpn&y  in  H^.  militia,  «id  dcsinwa  {h«|aUekctio«iO(^i>f. 

yriinr  Ix^iAcgr  t*  q|iui!f%  vacancyi  ercated  ^r  0>«i«ri|pMtia 
Lofiitt,  toliefill«|3bMaMJ«(ir{No«#«  9^$l^>'  ^^*    ' 

.     ^   it       \  *  }>A»II||  KAms*  M-J.  Mst-BriteSd  1 


y'^\ 


V. 


»V.j 


•If 


hadiwn  datfiwdlgt Gen. Goodale  who  preBd^d,  crfriedjti? «f«o«c^ 
of  tlw  Adjiitailltitan«|a^>y  C^»L  Brimbtecom,  who  testified  on  ij^^lil, 


•>, 


' '".  k 


AdjUtMBt 

.''*} 

-  ♦  ■ 

/• 

-4-  - 

■ .  #■■ 

-.i 

«,.' 

• 

thitt  he  uoM  Gil.  ^Ocomh  md  l^ley  Pu&am  in  B6aton. 
rode  with  tiiejpeeji  of  couriew  whe%carrying  newa  vtj 
direct^ tt>li|pth#fr  friends  at  the  CoimcUChainl^^ 
<6oT.  Gerry,|mlfiuit  ^^w^^of  oflM*  th^y  »»ifet» 
<»ni^i||#non il)i|^(%JI^TU^  u  iiimih* 

kfthi»bci^|||iNf^<iiMllNl|^^ 


le^pili:^ 


f 


*,».. 


.;^^ 
^ 


«»i 


4^ 


*» 


^^ 


k. 


*,>» 


4 


Ftttnan.  and  his  hnMilii''0bnfMity'fviiuu^ 


^  *      -"'  Chunbcr,  where  from  the  hi^of  tioMS^errf^  Sedtij^.  Hoauns,  tl**  it^^;^^^ 

received  the  «oMiiissi9iri  they  t1|ence  wentte  the  oStWo^^  Adjjjj^l '    -'" 
i»Cenetal,  who  adminutered  the  oath  to  (now)  den.  Da^d  Putnam.        ^  > 


4 


'. .    U,  '       %^«      '  "*  '*"*  ^''**  ■*"'•'*  ^^"^7*  E«q.  the  BeniorCblooel  in  the  B)^»de 


[*>i'^ 


» 


!3k ' 


■         ar**^^  ''*^  served  nBMiymw  in  the  Hevol^onaTy  Watu-and  who4  | 

character  is  highly  tespectabfe^  BUperscded!  ^  .*w* '  il 

f  ^    \Br%*di^  General  David  Putnam  and  his  Brigade' Migor,'*l>ainMi    -W^*, 

Cuii^ming]^  Hre  indebted  for  their  pfomotioff^jlpii|,  ^ttjki^  iji Ji  Wkll*'     ^ 

disbdiiorai^i  means  unfolded  in  the  preeeding^^^^^^  £e  wnM^^ 
'  tent  ^th  the  A»iw/of va  soldier  or  the  integrip  of  ^(^Hk'ii'f  h^  *y        « 
sv  fcrce  dnd  in  despite  of  the  majmity,  ^cet  thus  obeu2IW6en.  Goodidc  -^^  '  " 
,^  s'"  Jias  efendedt-^vl  he  has  tuffereit-4ba  bu||der  by  which  they  ascteiti,^^  I 

^^  has  bni&eh  and  is  kicked  away.    And  n«w,  reader,  whjit  in  truth%M|p      "  '  '|l'^7 

be  the^^«whidi  agitate  their  breavtsi  whenever  th^^'bi^idf^  J|    , 

ifx  their  m)||itaryoT^ment8  to  parade  in  preaence  of  ^fm^  tttHtmHiMl'  H   .  ;^ 

..  "^  *'^  '^'**"y  ''^  '^^  elpvatMO  will  ncnrer  ^  efEMMK  f ^  '  '  ' ;'   "  I  *  >«  v:^ 


V 


?!!•    i^-< 


^»  w. 


""V 


•!■ 


■.■v.,  ,.*tV-.  .^A/    »'»fV''-''-h  '■"'•'.' 


•  < 


:.*. 


%" 


'K* 


«> 


"Hfe^M^i;",.: 


.^ 


•A.'Vtt 


■5, 


■.l%i^- 


I,  '  I  :r 


1  ,■    •  '' 


..j'i'     ■:!' 


I'd  'I 


!'■., ,  ■  ■( 


Pt-  rl^k'    ':';■''■"'■ 


fp:"'" 


^ 


1  rr;-f 


s^'i.      ■   •■„■            ■    ' 

m 

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^P^ ' 

1 

\ 

' 

Wr^^W  ■■;■ 

Si'-  ■ ,  .   ■   ■ .. 
^'■■'■■' ■        „ 

H:  ■'...■■ 

1 

^^^^^HL     - 

^^^ 

^•#  I    ,■"                    1 
Vl,     ■■■^/  '.- 

■      ■         '           <■■■■         ■■•""'■      J\ 

Ik.  j^^^^^^r- 

•     •      ,       •         - '.  ■  •                 1 

^^^^^H 

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^Hp  » 

■  '^-       -  .••■  ^        '^ 

•     S. 

^^^^^ir                '":,. 

f 

r* 

0         '     > 

1       . 
ft                                                         ,,        »■        . 

',           ' 

i'    ' 

- 

'     "  .   ■ 

n    „ 

> 

. 

m                                           11  ■  t           II 

_.                         .                                                             0                      f 

*  -      ♦ 

'     ■                     .■   ^ 

'1:     ■      ■*.,.•■•■■' 

»  .», 

« 

'9                   ■  ''                        ,  , 

